AU/MIN/AGRI/3

CONFERENCE OF MINISTERS OF AGRICULTURE OF THE AFRICAN UNION
Maputo, Mozambique
1-2 July, 2003

Preparatory Meeting of Experts
1 July 2003

Item 3 of the Provisional Agenda

A BRIEF PRESENTATION OF THE PROCESS OF CONVERTING THE
COMPREHENSIVE AFRICA AGRICULTURE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME (CAADP) TO IMPLEMENTABLE PLANS OF ACTION AT NATIONAL AND REGIONAL LEVELS


1. INTRODUCTION
2. THE PREPARATION OF THE FIRST TRANCHE OF THE ACTION PLAN
3. MATTERS TO BE REFERRED TO MINISTERIAL ATTENTION
Annex 1: The Chronology of Events and Forums for Dialogue related to preparation of the NEPAD agriculture programme
Annex 2: NEPAD Agriculture Action Plan 2003-2009
Annex 3: NEPAD Action Plan Programme Themes
Annex 4: Declaration of Abuja


1. INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background

This note presents for information and consideration a set of projects representing a sample fulfilling the requirements of the NEPAD Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme (CAADP). With the entire CAADP programme calling for investment totalling some US$251 billion, there will clearly be need for stepwise and progressive implementation. The preparation of the first tranche of projects has offered some lessons regarding the process of converting the CAADP into implementable Action Plans, including on the roles of Regional Economic Communities and of the international community of partners, with focus at this stage having been at regional/sub-regional level.

Preparation of Action Plans represents a milestone in the NEPAD agriculture programme process. It may be recalled that at a special NEPAD-focused session of the FAO Regional Conference for Africa organised in Rome on 9th June 20021, African Ministers of Agriculture endorsed the NEPAD Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme (CAADP). The programme reflects NEPAD's vision of agriculture that seeks to restore agricultural growth, rural development and food security in the African region. Taking into account Africa's diverse potential, constraints and opportunities, the overall CAADP presents for most urgent attention, three mutually non-exclusive pillars to induce quickest production increases:

In addition, it presents a long-term pillar on agricultural research, technological dissemination and adoption.

In the context of the pillar on increasing food production and reducing hunger, the CAADP also puts emphasis on emergencies and disasters that require food and agricultural responses.

The Regional Economic Communities (RECs) / Regional Economic Organisations (REOs) have been given a prominent role in promoting and facilitating the implementation of NEPAD programmes and projects that involve groups of countries. In view of this and in order to create a stepping stone towards the operationalisation of CAADP from an Africa wide programme to a regional level and later to country level, the Chairman of NEPAD Steering Committee, the President of the African Development Bank (ADB), and the Director-General of FAO jointly convened a high-level meeting in Abuja 11-12 December 2002. The meeting promoted the engagement of Africa's RECs and REOs in implementing CAADP, as a contribution to fulfilling the NEPAD vision of agriculture. In preparation for this High-level Meeting, a joint ADB/FAO meeting of experts was held in Accra from 13 to 22 November, 2002 to prepare a technical document on the role of Regional Economic Organisations in the implementation of NEPAD/CAADP, that served as a base document for deliberation and preparation for the High-level Meeting in Abuja.

When it took place in December, the Abuja High Level Meeting benefited from the preparatory process; it provided a forum for dialogue among those Heads of State and Governments that chair Africa's RECs/REOs, Executive Heads of RECs/REOs, Regional Banks, Members of the NEPAD Steering Committee, African Professional Organisations in the agricultural sector (including NGOs), and some members of the multinational and bilateral donor community. The forum forged and built fruitful partnerships amongst the regional economic communities/organisations to promote co-ordination and implementation of regional and multi-country initiatives and programmes related to agriculture and food security. The Declaration adopted at Abuja is attached. Among other aspects, the meeting agreed that member states, in partnership with RECs/REOs, would pursue vigorous action to implement the CAADP and that an Action Plan would be preparedd2. Hence, a subsequent meeting was organised by the NEPAD Secretariat in co-operation with FAO from March 31 to April 9, 2003 to prepare an Action Plan.

1.2 Chronology of the Process

The course of preparation of the Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme (CAADP) followed a consultative process, with the key element of this process highlighted in Annex 1. The consultative process involved all African countries, with Ministers of Agriculture being requested for comments on all drafts. In addition, other UN bodies and development partners offered important inputs, comments and suggestions. These include: the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD), the World Food Programme (WFP), the World Bank, the East African Development Bank and the African Development Bank (ADB). Comments and suggestions were also received from Regional Economic Communities and Organisations. The preparation of the Action Plan for the implementation of CAADP followed a similar consultative process. It involved the participation of many partners including: NEPAD Secretariat, RECs/REOs, African Development Bank (ADB), FAO, International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD), World Food Programme (WFP), World Bank/Regional Office, Development Bank of Southern Africa (DBSA), Forum for Agricultural Research in Africa (FARA), International Service for National Agricultural Research (ISNAR/regional office), and a representative of African farmers'organisations3.

2. THE PREPARATION OF THE FIRST TRANCHE OF THE ACTION PLAN

2.1 Purpose and Objective of the Plan

The purpose of the first set of projects under the CAADP Plan of Action is to provide the road map for the realisation of the NEPAD vision of agriculture under specified themes, while ensuring the following important elements in the process:

As preparation of Action Plans progresses until the entire CAADP is covered, the same principles will need to apply; furthermore, the primary role of national level NEPAD programmes will need to be stressed, bearing in mind the need for synergy and harmony among such initiatives so that Africa can move ahead with collective momentum.

2.2 Key Elements of the Plan and its process

This Plan of Action should be perceived as the beginning of a process to kick-start with immediate action the implementation of the NEPAD vision of agriculture (CAADP). The following key elements stand out as outputs of the Plan:

Box 1: Selection Criteria for NEPAD Programmes/projects

  • The proposal should demonstrate how it adds value to the operationalisation of the NEPAD/CAADP through:
    • Capacity to respond rapidly to agricultural crises in Africa;
    • Bring greater attention to issues critical to growth and/or reducing vulnerability;
    • Lending a more holistic view to problems now dealt with in "piecemeal" fashion;
    • Scaling up of proven technologies;
  • Have a regional scope with high impact at national level that addresses issues of regional convergence and integration.
  • Comply with national and regional priorities as evidenced by commitments through cost sharing
  • Be aligned with one or more of the pillars of CAADP:
    • Extending the are under sustainable land management and reliable water control systems;
    • Improving rural infrastructure and market access including inputs and finance;
    • Increasing food supply and reducing hunger;
    • Agricultural research, technology dissemination and adoption;
  • Have clear and visible linkages to Millennium Development Goals (MDG) of reducing hunger and poverty by half by 2015 and gender disparities.
  • Promote the development, sharing and transfer of expertise.

2.3 Highlights

As a way towards realising the goal of the NEPAD vision of agriculture through implementation of the CAADP, the Action Plan highlights the following:

2.4 Guiding Principles and Conditions for Success

The overall message is that the Action Plan is part of the process aimed at spearheading the realisation of the NEPAD vision of agriculture. In preparing and presenting the Action Plan, great efforts have been made to emphasise that its first version is only the beginning of the process for the implementation of CAADP. The process has enabled NEPAD to initiate transformation of the Africa-wide programme to the regional level. More needs to be done at the regional level and CAADP actions should be undertaken also at national level.

Underlying the Action Plan and prospects for its success are a number of guiding principles, of which the following can be highlighted:

3. MATTERS TO BE REFERRED TO MINISTERIAL ATTENTION

There are vital decisions that must be made and guidance given to NEPAD and RECs/REOs future activities. The following recommendations are being proposed for consideration and decision by the Ministers:

Annex 1: The Chronology of Events and Forums for Dialogue related to preparation of the NEPAD agriculture programme

Annex 2: NEPAD Agriculture Action Plan 2003-2009

First tranche of NEPAD flagship agriculture projects

Project Description

Tentative Project Cost (US Million)

Lead Agencies

CAADP PILLAR 1. Extending the Area Under Sustainable Land Management and Reliable Water Control Systems

7,408

Three RECs

1.1 Irrigation Development Project

1,008

COMESA

1.2 Irrigation Development and Water Management Project

500

SADC

1.3 Irrigation Development and Water Management Project

5,400

ECOWAS

1.4 Socio-Economic Development Program for Oncho-Freed Zones of West Africa

500

ECOWAS

CAADP PILLAR 2. Rural Infrastructure and Trade-related Capacities for Improved Market Access

28

Four RECs

2.1 Regional Agricultural Trade Promotion and Food Security Project

9

COMESA

2.2 Promotion of Regional Agricultural Trade and SPS Standards

8

ECOWAS

2.3 Promoting Regional Agricultural Trade and Harmonising SMS Standards

10

SADC

2.4 Studies and expert consultation with regard to the trade of AMU countries.

0.3

AMU

2.5 Reinforcement of phytosanitary control.

1

AMU

2.6 Information system with regard to food safety and agricultural development of the AMU

Not yet costed

AMU

2.7 Training for multilateral trade negotiations and the Agricultural Agreement

Not yet costed

AMU

CAADP PILLAR 3. Increasing Food Supply and Reducing Hunger

8,193

Six RECs

3.1 Agricultural Intensification and Diversification

8

ECCAS

3.2 Production and Commercialisation of High Yield Seeds and Planting Materials

10

ECCAS; ECOWAS

3.3 Promoting Sustainable Crop and Livestock Production in the Arid and Semi-Arid Lands: IGAD (US$30 million); ECOWAS (US$70 million)

100

IGAD; ECOWAS

3.4 Strategic Food Reserve Facility

200

SADC

3.5 Cassava Development Initiative for Sub-Sahara Africa

275

ECOWAS, ECCAS, COMESA

3.6 Disaster Prevention and Emergency Response Food Crises Program

7,500

ECCAS, ECOWAS, COMESA, IGAD, SADC

3.7 De-mining lands for agricultural production

100

ECCAS

3.8 Strengthening and broadening of the national Special Programmes for Food security.

Not yet costed

AMU

CAADP PILLAR 4. Agricultural Research, Technology Dissemination and Adoption

92

Four RECs, NEPAD and FARA

4.1 Agricultural Research and Technology Transfer for Strategic Crops (Tissue Culture Banana (Us$30 million); Nerica Rice (US$20 million); Pigeon peas (US$20 million); and Sweet potatoes (US$20 million)

90

ECOWAS, ECCAS, SADC, COMESA

4.2 Building and Strengthening Networks of Centres of Excellence in Agricultural Sciences

2

NEPAD, FARA

CAADP ALL PILLARS (1-4)

20

NEPAD, RECs & their member countries; and CSOs

Civil Society Mobilising and Empowerment Programme

20

NEPAD-SEC/CSOs

TOTAL COST

15,641

 

As indicated in the document, the programmes and projects in this first tranche is only a small fraction of what would eventually be needed to implement the CAADP. NEPAD, RECs/REOs will continue consultations with countries and countries themselves will need to formulate national NEPAD-related programmes to be reflected in their development plans and budgets. Regarding budget levels, a point to stress is that all numbers are only indicative at this stage and that none imply commitment by any "Lead Agency" or any of its partners whether individually or collectively.

Annex 3: NEPAD Action Plan Programme Themes

The Action Plan will undergo continuous evolution. In the first round, it was considered desirable to identify some programmes as "short-term" and others for the longer horizon. Among the short term ones are initiatives for which programmes and projects have already been prepared or those where such preparation is imminent or urgent. The medium to long-term programmes/projects are presented here for convenience under the pillars of the CAADP.

Short Term Programmes

Medium to Long Term programmes/projects

Pillar I: Programmes on Land Improvement and Water Management

Irrigation, which will be an important part of the programme package, is fundamental to agricultural intensification. It is to be undertaken at three levels: expansion of large-scale irrigation systems; rehabilitation of formal irrigation systems and; informal on-farm and small-scale irrigation and water control development. Related land and water themes (which are not necessarily proposed in the first set of flagship programmes in Annex 1) include:

Pillar II: Programmes On Rural Infrastructure and Trade-Related Capacities for Market Access

Development of infrastructure has in the past not always been located in such a way as to benefit agriculture. Similarly, location of agricultural development has not always taken account of the location of infrastructure necessary for its development, whether transport, ports, energy, water. NEPAD, RECs and countries can work towards more inter-sectoral dialogue for economically and mutually beneficial location of infrastructure relative to foci of agricultural development. The following actions, to be undertaken by national governments and RECs/REOs, represent priority areas for promoting intra-regional trade from which African countries can benefit:

Infrastructure

Access to markets

Addressing the issue of falling and unstable prices for African Exports

The problem of falling and/or unstable prices for exports has led to strong African Union interest in Protecting the prices of export commodities on the international market. There have been suggestions that an additional CAADP pillar could be proposed for this activity but given the prior agreements already concluded on the CAADP pillars, an interim solution could be the inclusion of this dimension under pillar 2, sub-section on Trade-related Capacities for market access.

The statutory underpinnings of this concern are in Article 46, Chapter VIII of the treaty establishing the African Economic Community, which proposes the establishing of an African Commodity Exchange. To this end, the African Commodity Exchange can play a major role in the protection of regional and continental markets primarily for the benefit of African agricultural products. The African Commodity Exchange can also be a conduit for the provision of food aid to Member States in the event of serious food shortage.

Market access cannot be pursued in isolation from agricultural and agro-industry production. Implementation of the programmes will be guided by this perspective:

Pillar III: Programmes to increase food supply and reduce hunger

This first tranche of projects is overwhelmingly focused on combating emergencies and preparedness for recurrences; in the immediate future, additional programmes and projects to support non-emergency agriculture and agro-industry will be drawn up. This is necessary to ensure that emergency-response capacity is anchored in dependable production within Africa rather than dependence on food stock from aid or external commercial imports:

Pillar IV: Strengthening of Research and Promotion of Technologies

Non-Pillar investments:

CAADP will require parallel investments in enabling conditions for agricultural renewal; such things as policy and strategy development and development of human and institutional capacities will fall under this heading. Examples are below:

Capacity Building

Policy and strategy reforms

From the above themes and project ideas. a number of NEPAD flagship programmes/projects have been prepared to the stage of Programme/Project Profiles and Concept Notes. A total of 21 Project profiles and project concepts for the period 2003-2009 have been prepared by the RECs/REOs as tabulated in Annex 2.


Annex 4: Declaration of Abuja

Declaration of the Heads State and Government Chairpersons of Regional Economic Communities on the NEPAD Vision for Agricultural Development and Food Security in Africa

Abuja, Nigeria, 12 December 2002

Preamble

We the Heads of State and Governments, and our representatives, in our capacity as Chairpersons of African Regional Economic Communities (RECs) are assembled in Abuja under the auspices of the NEPAD for the purpose of agreeing on the way forward in implementing regional programs for food security in the context of the NEPAD Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme (CAADP). We meet at a time of crisis, with Africa's economic growth stagnant; per capita income and food production in decline; and unacceptably high incidence of poverty, food insecurity and child malnutrition; growing dependence on food aid and food imports; as well as an increasingly marginal role for Africa in international trade. We believe that agriculture has potential to make a major contribution to reversing this state of affairs. In view of this, and:

  1. Recalling the decision of the Assembly of Heads of State and Government of the Organization of African Unity at its 37th ordinary session in Lusaka, Zambia in July 2001 to adopt the New African Initiative, thereafter renamed the New Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD) at the inaugural meeting of the Heads of State and Government Implementation Committee in Abuja, Nigeria on 23 October 2001;
  2. Strongly concerned at the difficulties faced by all African countries, in particular the current food crisis in Southern Africa and the Horn of Africa and the situation faced by countries affected by violent conflict, civil strife, natural disasters such as frequent droughts and floods and exposed to the adverse effects of desertification;
  3. Concerned further about the marginal position of Africa in the global economy and the great prevalence of food insecurity and poverty across the continent which undermine the dignity of Africa's people and weaken the basis for sustainable peace and security;
  4. Recognising the fundamental role and importance of agriculture as a source of food security and economic activity for Africa's people and convinced of its potential to help reverse economic decline;
  5. Further recalling that during the World Food Summit: five years later held in Rome at which African Ministers for Agriculture met on 9 June 2002, under the umbrella of the FAO Regional Conference for Africa and endorsed the NEPAD Vision of Agriculture as presented in the Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme, which seeks an early reversal of agricultural malaise and provides a framework for priority agricultural investments;
  6. Noting with satisfaction the positive reaction of the international community during the World Food Summit: five years later, at the adoption of NEPAD and inclusion of an agriculture and food security component;
  7. Concerned at the current downward trend of the agricultural budgets of African countries and the decline in the Official Development Assistance (ODA) and International Financial Institutions portfolios that are directly allocated to agriculture as a contribution to food security;
  8. Noting that the workshop organised by the UN Economic Commission for Africa in Addis-Ababa in August 2002 drew attention to the roles of Regional Economic Communities (RECs) and national governments as NEPAD implementation bodies. Noting further the major role that RECs can play in promoting, co-ordinating and intensifying the unity and solidarity of African States in implementing programmes that would enhance food security, agricultural productivity and trade at both regional and national levels;
  9. Welcoming the fact that a number of African Regional Economic Communities (RECs) have taken a step forward by preparing Regional Programmes for Food Security (RPFS);
  10. Aware of the potential that Africa's rich endowment promises and convinced that NEPAD offers a new opportunity to realise it:

Declaration

11. We hereby commit ourselves to:

  1. The NEPAD vision that seeks to stop the demise of the African economy within fifteen years through establishment of an enabling environment for sustained development;
  2. Pursuing vigorous action for the implementation of the main pillars of action of the CAADP; as reflected in a Plan of Action that will be prepared at a later stage, in collaboration with RECs;
  3. Implementing Regional Programmes for Food Security in close co-ordination with corresponding initiatives at the national level;
  4. Promoting the recognition of agriculture as a priority sector in Africa including the allocation of increased funding in national budgets as recommended by the African ministers of agriculture at the follow-up session of the 22nd FAO Regional Conference for Africa (Rome, June 2002);
  5. Strengthening the capacities of RECs so that they can effectively serve as building blocks for the integration of the continent in the context of the African Union, and can play a lead role in implementing the programmes;
  6. Taking all necessary measures to engage the private sector and to mobilise all the energies and resources of civil society in the implementation of NEPAD agricultural programmes.

12. We urge member governments to join in ensuring the creation of an enabling environment for sustainable agricultural development and to favour the rational use and protection of natural resources, in particular land and water, including by:

  1. a high level of political commitment to implementation of programmes in agriculture, rural development, and food security;
  2. a suitable policy and institutional environment for sustainable agriculture;
  3. gender and youth concerns in agriculture, nutrition and food security, and create an enabling environment for the enhancement of livelihood opportunities of young men and women;
  4. the devastating effects of HIV/AIDS and malaria on agriculture, by all means at our disposal;
  5. human, institutional and resource mobilisation capacities;
  6. capacity to address disasters and emergencies which could otherwise threaten long term development;
  7. natural resources and encouraging the rehabilitation of degraded lands, in particular de-mining arable land;
  8. the establishment of safety nets through school feeding programmes to guarantee nutritional requirements of the African child.

13. We note with appreciation the positive role that lead agencies such as ADB and FAO have played over the past year in support of NEPAD and call upon them to continue to support activities for promoting commitment to agriculture and food security. We encourage them and all other members of the donor community, especially African development partners, to render increased support to RECs and member countries in the preparation and implementation of short, medium, and long term bankable projects.

14. We encourage RECs to develop a dynamic partnership with farmers organisations networks and agricultural chambers in the preparation and implementation of Programmes reflecting the NEPAD vision.

15. We express our profound appreciation to His Excellency President Olusegun Obasanjo, the government and the people of the Federal Republic of Nigeria for their warm hospitality. We also thank the Economic Community of West African States for the excellent arrangements made for hosting the meeting and convening the other RECs.

Done in Abuja, 12 December 2002


1 At the request of the NEPAD Steering Committee, the Programme was prepared by the NEPAD Secretariat in co-operation with the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
2 At their Rome meeting of June 2002, the African Ministers of Agriculture had recommended, inter alias, to . . ."prepare a plan of action incorporating national and regional plans, to include the timeframe for the implementation of the programme, as well as the specification of the expected outputs and performance indicators;" and to . . ."formulate projects for financing at the regional, sub-regional and national levels under the framework of the CAADP priorities and, in doing this, to give attention to country and sub-regional diversity".
3 Represented by the Réseau des organisations paysannes et de producteurs de l'Afrique de l'Ouest (ROPPA).
4 These were also based on discussions from the Abuja technical and preparatory meeting for Heads of State and Governments, December 2002.