INTRODUCTION AND USE OF OAT CULTIVARS IN PAKISTAN

Ashiq Hussain, Sartaj Khan, M.U. Mufti and Allah Bakhsh

Fodder Programme, National Agricultural Research Centre, PO NIH, Park Road
Islamabad 45500, Pakistan

Abstract

Oats is a major cereal fodder crop of winter season in Pakistan. The developments in various aspects and use of oats in the country includes: oat harvested for fodder at or before 50% flowering stage showed better compromise of reasonable fodder yield as well as fodder quality. Harvesting of oat for fodder after 100 or 115 days of planting and then seed at maturity provided a good package of fodder yield, seed yield and fodder quality. Varieties PD2-LV65, Sargodha–81 and No. 725 are better in fodder yield and quality under agro-climatic environments of Islamabad. Oat varieties Jasper and PD2-LV65 gave an excellent performance across different ecologies of the country. Peshawar (North West Frontier Province) and Islamabad areas are better for quality oat fodder production. Application of fertilizer at the rate of 150-kg nitrogen and 25 kg phosphorus to oats crop is economical for optimum fodder production (18.23 t/ha dry matter). Oat + vetch (50:50) mix cropping should be disseminated for quality fodder production. Improved oats fodder production technology has 152 % more income than farmer’s technology. Various research institutes in the country have released nine oat varieties for general cultivation for fodder.

Introduction

Oats (Avena sativa L.) is one of the most important cereal fodder crops grown in winter throughout Pakistan both under irrigated and rain fed conditions. Temperate and cool sub-tropical conditions are congenial for its growth. A well-distributed rainfall of 400 mm and an optimum temperature range 16-32oC during the four months duration is sufficient to meet its requirement as a fodder crop. It is a quick growing, palatable, succulent and nutritious crop and forms an excellent combination when fed along with other cold season legumes, like berseem or Egyptain clover (Trifolium alexandrinum), Lucerne or alfalfa (Medicago sativa), Indian clover (Melilotus indica), Persian clover (Trifolium resupinatum) and pea (Pisum arvense), or vetch (Vicia sativa). The oats can provide green fodder after 60-70 days in emergency to tide over the scarcity period but after 90-100 days to get large quantity of fodder. Oats fodder is mostly fed as green and surplus is converted into silage or hay for use during the fodder deficit periods. It is favorite feed of all animals and its straw is soft and superior to wheat and barley. It is high in TDN, protein, fat, vitamin B1 and minerals as phosphorus and iron. The oats grain is particularly valuable feed for horses, dairy cows, poultry and young breeding animals of all kinds. Comparative fodder yield and quality performance of winter cereal fodders is shown in Table 1.

Table 1: Green fodder yield (t/ha), dry matter yield (t/ha) and crude protein (%) of oats, barley and wheat.

Crop                   Green fodder                       Dry matter                       Crude protein

Oats                             64.60                              11.40                                    8.10

Barley                          56.30                              10.20                                    7.72

Wheat                          30.60                                7.00                                    7.50

Stage of Maturity and effect of cutting

The growth or maturity is a very important factor that influences the quality of oat. In general, with the advancement of maturity, dry matter yield, acid detergent fiber, neutral, detergent fiber, hemi-cellulose, cellulose, lignin and silica increase while crude protein and cell contents in the whole plant and plant parts decrease in concentration. It is a well-established fact that high concentration of cell wall contents is associated with low intake and digestibility. Higher lignin and silica contents also depress the digestibility of structural carbohydrate. It has been observed that cell wall constituents and dry matter contents increase in the subsequent cuttings while the crude protein contents start declining in the later cuttings. The plants become weak by too early and frequent cuttings and are usually more susceptible to drought, heat, winter injury and prevalent diseases. On the other hand delayed harvesting till maturity does not offer any compromise between maximum forage yield, high protein and increased digestibility. Cutting at early growth stages is essential to obtain better quantity and quality of the forages. Therefore, a compromise is necessary in forage management for maximum vigor of plants and maximum quality of forage. Fodder yields and crude protein of oats and barley under different cutting stages are presented in Tables 2 and 3.

Table 2: Dry matter yields (t/ha) and crude protein contents (%) of oats and barely at various cutting stages.
Cutting
Stage
Oats
Barley
Dry matter protein Crude protein Dry matter Crude
CS-1 5.80 14.93 4.80 13.47
CS-2 7.10 14.07 5.70 12.78
CS-3 10.60 12.65 7.40 11.70
CS-4 12.40 10.80 9.20 9.85
CS-5 12.10 8.75 8.00 8.42
CS-6 11.40 8.10 10.20 7.72
CS-7 13.30 7.63 11.10 7.54
CS-8 13.90 7.50 13.40 7.02
CS-9 17.10 7.15 14.60 6.85

CS-1, Repeated cutting at 4-Ieaf stage; CS-2, repeated cutting at tillering stage; CS-3, repeated cutting at jointing stage; CS-4, repeated cutting at booting stage; CS-5, harvesting once at head emergence stage; CS-6, harvesting once at 50% flowering stage; CS-7, harvesting once at 100% flowering stage; CS-8, harvesting once at early milk stage; and CS-9, harvesting once at early dough stage.

Table 3: Green fodder yield (t/ha), dry matter yield (t/ha) crude protein contents (%) of oats at various cutting stages.

Variety/cutting stage   Green fodder yield      Dry matter yield           Crude protein

PD2-LV65

Pre-booting                              61.10                           13.70                           8.40

Booting                                    64.40                           15.20                           7.44

After-booting                            63.90                           21.00                           7.16

Avon

Pre-booting                              51.10                           15.80                           8.56

Booting                                    60.30                           16.90                           7.50

After-booting                            59.40                           22.10                           7.21

Increased Dry Matter Yield

Generally maximum yield and quality do not go hand in hand. It has been observed in almost all the forage crops that the percentage of crude protein and total cell contents decrease with the increase in dry matter yield. Also, the percentage of various cell wall contents tends to increase with the increase in dry matter contents. Since higher concentration of cell wall constituents are generally related to reduced intake and low digestibility, therefore, higher dry matter yield in forages would be accompanied by a decline in desirable quality traits and increase in undesirable quality traits. Therefore, a compromise between maximum dry matter yield and desirable quality traits needs to be made which is not impossible. Effect of harvesting stage on forage yield, seed yield and crude protein contents is shown in Table 4.

Table 4: Dry matter yield (t/ha), seed yield (t/ha) and crude protein contents (%) of oats under different cutting intervals.

Cutting treatment       Dry matter yield                     Seed yield       Crude protein

CT 1                             1.98                                        1.86                             14.41

CT 2                            3.31                                        1.77                             13.03

CT 3                             5.35                                        1.48                             10.39

CT 4                             7.41                                        1.41                               8.67

CT 5                           14.29                                           -                                  7.79

CT 6                               -                                            2.19                                 -


LSD (0.01)                   0.99                                        0.47                              0.27

CT 1, cutting for fodder 70 days after sowing (DAS) and then for seed at maturity; CT 2, cutting for fodder 85 DAS and then for seed at maturity; CT 3, cutting for fodder 100 DAS and then for seed at maturity; CT 4, cutting for fodder 115 DAS and then for seed at maturity; CT 5, cutting at 50% flowering stage for fodder only; and CT 6, cutting for seed only at maturity.

Fodder Varieties

Results of extensive research on oats varieties have indicated a tremendous amount of genetic variation for their fodder yield and quality potential. The most interesting feature of the studies is that there is a wide variation for structural carbohydrates and crude protein contents in varieties harvested at the same growth stage and time. It is encouraging that choice of selection for maximum forage yield and quality is possible. The forage yield and Crude protein of various cultivars of oats observed at the National Agricultural Research Centre (NARC), Islamabad is presented in Table 5.

Table 5: Green fodder (t/ha), dry matter (t/ha) yield and crude protein contents (%) of various oats varieties.

Variety              Green Fodder      Dry Matter                 Crude Protein

S-81                      75.06                             8.98                           10.94

PD2-LV65            82.83                           12.08                           10.06

Avon                     68.67                             9.26                             9.65

No. 656               70.97                             9.53                           12.44

No 681                71.45                             9.41                           12.24

No.725                81.32                           11.84                           11.66

SS-l                     71.30                             9.83                           10.21

S-141                  71.14                           10.68                           10.33

No.707                67.44                             9.67                           10.09


LSD (0.01)          8.55                             2.05                             0.62


 

Response of' oats varieties under two-cut system at National Agricultural Research Centre, Islamabad Pakistan under irrigated conditions for forage yield is summarized in Table 6. First cutting, 70 days after sowing and second cutting, at 50% flowering stage.

Table 6: Dry matter yields (t/ha) of different oats cultivars under two-cut system in Pakistan

Variety                                       Dry matter yields

                              1st cutting                     2nd cutting                        Total

PD2-LV65                   5.80                             20.71                           26.51

S-81                            5.90                             21.60                           27.50

Swan                            5.23                             17.80                           23.03

DN-8                           5.18                             17.90                           23.08

Kent                             4.63                             16.50                           21.13

Avon                            3.94                             17.63                           21.57

Golden rein                   5.10                             15.50                           20.60

Crude Proteins

It is a well-established fact that if feeds contain less than 7 percent crude protein, the animals are likely to be deficient in nitrogen; hence less productive. Cereal fodder crops are generally poor in crude protein content and digestibility as compared to leguminous fodder crops. It has been found that a minimum protein content of 5-6 percent is essential for the maintenance of animals and 9-10 percent for production purpose under sub- tropical conditions. The crude protein contents of cereal fodder crop can be improved by; nitrogen application in the soil, inter cropping legume fodder in cereal fodder crops and feeding protein supplements to livestock.

Inter-cropping of Legume Fodders in Cereal Fodders

Low application of nitrogenous fertilizer is the main cause of low fodder yield and poor quality of majority of cereal fodder crops like oats and barley. The critical level of 6-9 percent crude protein is required in fodder crops otherwise intake wi1l be reduced by nitrogen deficiency. For example, almost all the forage sorghum varieties cut at 50 percent flowering stage generally contain less than 8 percent crude protein. Different cereal fodder crops like millet, sorghum, maize, oats, Sudan grass, etc. contain average crude protein contents of 8.20, 5.90, 6.70, 6.55 and 5.72 percent, respectively. On the other hand different leguminous fodder crops like berseem, vetch, cowpea, guar, Lucerne, moth bean and Indian clover are best sources of nutritious fodder and contain 16.90. 15.65, 17.50, 16.65, 17.80, 15.22 and 19.12 percent crude protein contents, respectively. Therefore, to achieve maximum quantity and quality of fodder crops intercropping of legumes in cereal fodder crops would be desirable and beneficial. Average green fodder and dry matter yields of oats and vetch grown alone and in various sowing mixtures under + nitrogen fertilizer are given in Table 7.

Table 7: Average green and dry matter yields (t/ha) of oats and vetch grown alone and in various sowing mixtures and under + nitrogen fertilizer.

Treatments                             Green Fodder Yield                           Dry Matter Yield


- Nitrogen

Vetch alone                                          29.40 C                                               6.05 C

Oat+vetch (25-75)                               37.00 B                                                8.50 B

Oat+vetch (50-50)                               36.80 B                                                8.42 B

Oat+ vetch (75-25)                              35.77 B                                                7.93 B

Oats alone                                             29.20 C                                               7.56 B

+ Nitrogen

Vetch alone                                          29.23 C                                               05.86 C

Oat+vetch (25-75)                               45.47 A                                               10.27 A

Oat+vetch (50-50)                               47.17 A                                               10.97 A

Oat+vetch{75-25)                                47.90 A                                               11.03 A

Oats alone                                            44.30 A                                               10.33 A

Means followed by the same letters do not differ significantly at the 5% level.

Importance of Location

Results of numerous research findings have indicted marked influence of temperature and environment on the quality and quantity of oats. It has widely been reported that the same variety performs differently for both forage yield and forage quality when planted under different agro-ecological environments. It might also be due to poor fertility status of the soil. Therefore, farmers should be careful in the selection of a variety for a particular locality and apply fertilizer on such types of soils to obtain maximum fodder yield and fodder quality. The performance of various oats varieties under different locations is given as under in Tables 8, 9 and 10.

Table 8: Green fodder yields (t/ha) of oats varieties at different locations in Pakistan.

Variety                                        Locations

                  Islamabad              Peshawar        Faisalabad      Tandojam        Quetta

Avon             76.91                  103.20             67.86               28.07               13.88

PD2-LV65   75.96                   120.30             81.74               32.03               22.22

Hakae           78.90                  110.50             70.36               33.56               19.90

Scott             80.60                  101.80             68.05               31.73               21.30

Foot Hill      80.51                    88.30               60.63               38.44               17.60

Hay               88.13                  116.60             68.51               27.31               21.66

Coolabah      90.94                  120.30             66.19               21.96               14.81

Jasper           90.84                  122.60             82.86               30.09               24.40

Table 9: Variety wise ranking of oats fodder yield (t/ha) in Pakistan.

Varieties                                             Green fodder                          Dry matter

Jasper                                                  70.15                                       19.43

PD2-LV65                                           66.45                                       18.40

Hay                                                      66.44                                       17.85

Coolabah                                             62.82                                       17.40

Hakae                                                  62.64                                       17.35

Scott                                                    60.70                                       16.81

Avon                                                    57.98                                       16.00

Foot Hill                                               57.10                                       15.81

Table 10: Location wise ranking of oats fodder yield (t/ha) and crude protein contents (%) in Pakistan.

Location                                  Green fodder        Dry matter           Crude protein

ARI, Tarnab Peshawar             110.45                         30.59                           8.05

NARC, Islamabad                    82.84                           22.94                           8.32

AARI, Faisalabad                     70.77                           19.60                           7.62

ARI, Tandojam                        40.00                           11.08                           7.20

ARRI Sariab, Quetta                19.47                             5.39                           6.34

Fertilizer Effect

Change in crude protein content of forage oat is the most important effect of nitrogen fertilizer. The other minerals mainly influence the forage yield and mineral contents. Although palatability may be affected but change in digestibility is relatively very low. Nitrogen application increases crude protein content, decreases soluble carbohydrates in leaves and stems, and promotes rapid lignifications in oats and other grasses. In most instances, nitrogen fertilizer relatively less influences digestibility, although it is often thought that this improves the quality of forage by increasing crude protein percentage. It was assessed that application of fertilizer @ 150 kg nitrogen and 25 kg phosphorus to oats crop is economical for optimum fodder production. The effect of nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer on oats is given in Table 11.

Table 11: Dry matter yields (t/ha) of oats under various N and P fertilizer treatments.

Fertilizer treatments                                                  Dry matter yield

N-P Kg/ha

100- 25                                                                                    17.02

50- 50                                                                                      14.56

50- 75                                                                                      13.85

150- 25                                                                                    18.23

150- 75                                                                                    19.97

100- 50                                                                                    17.63

00-00                                                                                       10.73

Economic Return

Traditionally, the farmers grow mostly barley and to some extent mustard as sole crops for fodder production during winter. On the basis of superiority of oats due to their higher fodder yields, more palatability and soft stem, barley was replaced with improved fodder oats. The results of improved fodder production technology vs traditional methods in medium rainfall areas showed that given the correct inputs farmers could improve their production substantially. It can result in increase in the profit of their dairy enterprise. The net income received under improved practice is 152% more than under farmer’s practice (Table 12).

Table 12: Comparison of farmer’s and improved fodder production technology of oats in medium rainfall areas of Pakistan.

Parameters                             Farmer's Practice                               Improved Practice

Fodder Yield (kg/ha)                16467                                                  38399

Per kg Cost (Rs)                      0.25                                                     0.25

Gross Return (Rs)                     4117                                                    9599

Production Cost (Rs)                1089                                                    1983

Net Return (Rs)                        3028                                                    7616

Increase over Farmer’s Practice                                                       152%

Improved Oats Seed Production in Pakistan

Improved seed of various oats varieties (PD2-LV65, S-81, S-2000, and Scott) was produced at the research centre/institutes is presented in Table 13.

Table 13: Improved oats seed production (tons) in Pakistan.

Year                                                                                        Seed produced

1992                                                                                                    10

1993                                                                                                    12       

1994                                                                                                    16

1995                                                                                                    22       

1996                                                                                                    27

1997                                                                                                    30

1998                                                                                                    35

1999                                                                                                    43

2000                                                                                                    45

2001                                                                                                    51

Approved Fodder Oats Varieties

The list of approved varieties of fodder oats released by various research institutes in Pakistan during 1961 to 2000 is shown in Table 14.

Table 14: Oats varieties released by different research institutes in Pakistan.

Name of Varieties                  Originating Institute                 Year of Registration

Palestine                                   AARI   Faisalabad                                            1961

Fatua                                        AARI   Faisa1abad                                           1962

Algerian                                    AARI   Faisa1abad                                           1963

W.No. 11                                AARI   Faisa1abad                                           1965

DN-8                                       ARI      Tarnab, Peshawar                                 1976

Avon                                        FRI      Sargodha                                              1983

PD2-LV65                               FRI      Sargodha                                              1983

Sargodha-81                            FRI      Sargodha                                              1983

Sargodha-2000                        FRI      Sargodha                                              2000

AARI, ARI and FRI denote Ayub Agricultural Research Institute, Agricultural Research Institute and Fodder Research Institute.

Summary

·  Oat harvested for fodder at or before 50% flowering stage proved good compromise of reasonable fodder yield as well as fodder quality.

·  Oats varieties PD2-LV65, Sargodha-81 and No 725 are better in fodder yield and fodder quality.

·  Peshawar and Islamabad areas are better for quality oat fodder production.

·  Application of fertilizer @ 150 kg nitrogen and 25 kg phosphorus to oats crop is economical for optimum fodder production (18.23 t/ha dry matter).

·        Oats + vetch (50:50) mix cropping should be disseminated for quality fodder production.

·        Improved oats fodder production technology has 152 % more income than farmer’s technology.

·        Various research institutes in the country have released nine oats varieties for general cultivation for fodder.

Back