REVIEW OF SELECTED NEW BOOKS ON RICE
Sustainable of Rice in the Global Food System
Impact of Rice Research
Rice Breeding: Research Priorities and Challenges
Quantifying the Effects of Land Conditions on Rice Growth
The Sustainable of Rice Farming
Allelopathy in Rice
Advances in Hybrid Rice Technology
Fertilization of Rice in Japan
1) Sustainability of Rice in The Global Food System
N.G. Dowling, S.M. Greenfield and K.S. Fisger, 1998. Pacific Basin Study Center and IRRI, Los Baños, Philippines 404 pp.
The overall objective
of this book is to examine rice production from many aspects of rice academic
and policy base, not only from the side of production and economics but also
from the involvement of generations of people of many cultures. Chapters 1 and
2 explain the importance of sustainability of rice in the global food system.
The international concern about the growing world population and declining food
supplies, especially in countries with the lowest average annual incomes. These
include some countries in Asia and Africa that need attention to policies and
research to provide a sustainable food supply. Chapters 2, 3 and 4 consider
the important aspects of food supply, mainly water, land and labour scarcities,
the importance of rice in diet, the cost of growing rice and the impact of income
production. Three case studies in China, Vietnam and Japan illustrate the potential
of small-scale wet rice farming as a sustainable basis for a diversified rural
economy. The elements for maintaining a sustainable rice system and developing
a larger framework and structures of regenerative food systems were examined.
Chapters 6 to 17, which deal with rice production systems, are a compilation
of papers prepared by specialists in rice at the International Rice Research
Institute. These papers present current and pending research on the sustainability
of rice in the food supply over the next 30 years. They cover challenges for
rice research in Asia, genetic enhancement of rice yields, intensification of
rice production systems: opportunities and limits, importance of rice pests
and challenges to their management, weeds: a looming problem in modern rice
production, management of water as a scarce resource, securing the future of
intensive rice system, rice and global environment, new frontier projects: beyond
the pipeline, protecting the diversity of tropical rice ecosystems, rice genetic
resources and biological diversity of rice landscapes. Chapters 18 and 19 focus
on economic issues, with emphasis on economic value of genetic rice improvement
and food, energy and the environment: implications for Asia's rice. Chapter
20 and 21 report case studies in rice production constraints in China and priorities
and opportunities of rice production and consumption in India. Finally, Chapter
22 made conclusions and proposed a potential research agenda.
2) Impact of Rice Research
Edited by P.L. Pingali and M. Hossain. 1998. Thailand Development Research Institute and IRRI, Los Baños, Philippines, 428 pp.
The publication is the
proceedings of the International Rice Conference on the Impact of Rice Research
held 3-5 June 1996 Bangkok, Thailand. It consists of 17 contributing papers
and an overview one. The contributing papers could be grouped into thematic
papers (8) and case study papers (9). Majority of the papers presented and discussed
the experiences gained in Asia. In general, authors of papers in this book agreed
that rice research has substantially contributed to the improvement of the food
security and the reduction of poverty.
The thrusts and activities of IRRI during the last 30 years were reviewed and
new directions for rice research were proposed in the first thematic paper.
In order to enable rice production to meet demand in the future, the authors
argued that rice research should give high priority to the raising of the yielding
potential of irrigated rice varieties using hybrid rice and super rice, improvement
of direct seeding practices for efficient water use of rice production, and
enhancement of farmers' knowledge in crop management practices. The next paper
quantified the economic returns of rice varietal improvement activities. It
was estimated that the value of rice varieties released by varietal improvement
programmes collaborating with the International Germplasm Evaluation for Rice
during the last 30 years worth about US$ 1.9 billion. Water is so essential
for successful rice production. The global water demand and supply in the future
were discussed in the third thematic paper, which postulated that less and less
water will be available for rice production. The authors suggested several options
for research and development in the future, which include the development of
small-scale irrigation, based on farmers' knowledge and the participation of
private sector in the development of ground water. In the fourth papers, the
authors considered that, with advances made in the field of communication, the
improvement of farmers' understanding and knowledge on why, when, and how to
apply production technologies will be an important area for rice research in
the future. The next paper on IPM (or Integrated Pest Management) served as
an example of the benefits of improving farmers' knowledge and understanding.
The impact of the Green Revolution on the rural poor was critically assessed
in the last thematic paper, in which the authors showed that the Green Revolution
has not substantially improve the living conditions of the rural poor. The authors,
however, reasoned that this was due to the high population growth rate.
In Asia, the case studies were carried out in Bangladesh, China, India, Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand, and Vietnam. The impact of rice research in Latin America was presented by the CIAT and that in West Africa was presented by WARDA. The results of many case studies strongly supported the views expressed in thematic papers on the positive impact of research. The case studies in Vietnam and Philippines, however, showed that rice research could produce real impact only when national policy is favourable for rice production. The analysis on the impact of research in the publication, however, did not cover the contribution of rice research to other areas such as the conservation of the environment and natural resources. It would be interesting, for example, to know what is the impact of rice research on global warming.
3) Rice Breeding and Genetics: Research Priorities and Challenges
Edited by Jata S. Nanda, Science Publishers Inc., Enfield, New Hampshire, 2000. 382 pp
The book provides a comprehensive
review of the challenges, progresses, and opportunities of research in breeding
and genetics of this world's most important food crop. Going through the whole
book, readers will realise the coherence in the arrangement of the 15 papers
and the preface of the book. While the preface briefly discussed the issues,
challenges and opportunities of sustainable rice production, the first paper
introduced the orientation and the possibilities of increasing yield potential
of rice varieties through breeding. The sequence of the second to the sixth
papers is a little confusing. The second paper reviewed and discussed the exploitation
of heterosis in rice for commercial application and its progresses. It also
provided the understanding of genetic basis of heterosis in rice and the breeding
of cytoplasmic (genetic) male sterility (CMS), fertility restoration, and genetic
male sterility. The third paper dealt with issues of sustainable integrated
rice production. The paper suggested that rice production should be viewed as
a part of holistic farming systems, in which farmers' incomes and welfare, as
well as the diversity of social, biological and physical environment, should
be integrated into the design of rice technologies. Sustainable rice production,
moreover, is possible only with appropriate national policies supported by concrete
programs. The development of high yielding and drought-submergence-tolerant
rice varieties, which is critical for the improvement of the welfare of millions
of rainfed rice farmers, remains elusive as reported in the fourth paper. This
paper reviewed the physiological and genetic basis of drought and submergence
in rice production. The development of New Plant Type of Rice, having yielding
potentials of about 25% over the existing high yielding varieties, its scientific
and genetic basis and its progresses were discussed in the fifth paper. In the
sixth paper, the genetics of hybrid sterility, its implication to the differentiation
of cultivated rice and its application for enhancement of heterosis in rice
were presented.
The current rice breeding strategies and approaches and their results in breeding
for resistance and/or tolerance to biotic and abiotic stresses in rice production
were reviewed and discussed in 4 papers, from the 7th to 10th. The application
of biotechnological tools, especially the molecular marker-based gene mapping,
in rice genomics and for varietal improvement was tackled in the 11th paper,
which marked the turning of the presentation to the second area of the book:
Genetics. The 11th paper was followed with the analysis on the opportunities,
achievements, and challenges in the exploitation of alien species in rice varietal
improvement (12th paper); the review of cytogenetics of rice (13th paper); the
discussion on the relationships among the species of the genus Oryza (14th paper);
and finally a hypothesis on the origin of O. sativa and its ecotypes (15th paper).
4) Quantifying the Effects of Land Conditions on Rice Growth
Davis Casanova, 1998. Gràfique Pacífic, Barcelona, Spain 219 pp.
This thesis represents
detailed research on the "rice-soil-weather" system of the Ebro Delta,
Spain, providing knowledge on how temperature, radiation, soil properties and
farm management determine rice growth. After an introductory chapter, the findings
are developed step by step. (i) Chapter 2 is an overview of conditions in the
study area. (ii) Chapter 3 focuses on the study of the soils creating a soil
geographic database of the northern part of the Ebro Delta. Four properties
were used for defining soil units: soil development, drainage status, texture
and salinity. (iii) Chapter 4 and 5 deal with rice growth under limited conditions.
Potential productions of 13 tons/ha were estimated, while maximum yields of
11 tons/ha were recorded at field level. In Chapter 4, the phenological development,
the daily dry matter production and the leaf area development of rice crop were
modelled. In Chapter 5, the use of remote sensing techniques at field level
for monitoring the rice crop status was tested. (iv) Chapter 6 and 7, analyse
rice growth in relation to soil properties and farm management. Two soil factors
were found to dominate the effects on yield: one was topsoil CEC (in strong
association with clay content) with a positive effect, and the other one was
soil salinity with a negative effect. High groundwater tables did not have significant
effects on rice yield, except when the water has a high salt content.
Four main groups of causes within crop status limited rice growth: potassium
and zinc shortage where a strong antagonism of either factor with sodium was
observed, low plant establishment where a minimum number of 160-180 plants m2
was necessary to maximise yield, and length of growing season, especially the
length of the pre-heading period in which potential size of the crop was primarily
determined. Potassium and zinc shortage in the plant was mainly induced by soil
salinity. High K in saline soils did not increase K uptake. It remains to be
determined if addition of Zn will increase Zn uptake. Information on environmental
conditions of the study area and data on rice cropping is presented so that
farmers, extension workers and decision-makers find themselves in a better position
to adapt their management and policy making. This thesis intends to support
development of decision systems and to increase cooperation between agricultural
and environmental scientists focusing on concerns of society.
5) The Sustainability of Rice Farming
D.J. Greenland. IRRI and CAB International, 1997, 273 pages
The main content of the
book is contained in 9 chapters, covering about 235 pages. The historical perspective
of rice cultivation and the importance of sustainable rice production to food
security and the economic development of the rice consuming population of the
world were discussed in Chapters 1 to 2. Chapter 3 defines the rice production
systems and the productivity of each system. The factors affecting sustainable
rice production were discussed in detail in Chapter 4 (on biophysical factors),
Chapter 5 (on nutrient requirements and supplies), Chapter 6 (water requirement
and supplies in rice production and the effect of irrigation on the physical
environment of rice production), and Chapter 7 (socio-economic aspects of rice
production). The concerns about the sustainability of rice farming and the potentials
were raised in Chapter 8 and the opportunities for improving sustainable rice
production were discussed in Chapter 9.
The book could be considered as a synthesis of the knowledge on rice research
and production, especially on those, which were made during the last 30 years.
It provides readers with basic understanding of the factors affecting the sustainability
of rice farming and the needed actions for sustaining "this sustainability"
in order to produce enough rice to meet the continuously increasing demand for
rice of the world population. Although it was divided in 9 Chapters, the book
gives more attention to the physico-environment of rice production, especially
land and soil factors and their management for sustainable rice production.
The genetic diversity and varietal improvement were discussed in the book; it
is rather short and superficial. The book, nevertheless, acknowledged the important
contribution of high yielding varieties to the increases in rice production,
especially during the last 30 years, and the importance of raising the yield's
ceiling of rice varieties in sustainability of rice farming. The major weakness
of the book, however, is probably the lack of an in-depth analysis on the role
of national (and maybe international) policies on sustainable rice production.
The author's observation on the important role of "fertilizer-based farming
systems" on the sustainability of rice farming is particularly relevant.
The author opined that "It is no exaggeration to say that the future of
mankind depends on the sustainability of fertilizer-based farming systems. Although
some may question this fact and urge a return to organic farming systems, such
systems can do no more than recycle the nutrient elements that exists in the
soil. They may maintain present productivity but cannot raise productivity to
the extent demanded unless more land is used. Therefore, in poor areas, organic
farming systems will do no more than recycle poverty. For better areas, they
will force the exploitation of marginal lands and increase the pace of land
degradation".
6) Allelopathy in Rice
Edited by M. Olofsdotter, IRRI, 1998, 154 pages
The book is the outcome
of a workshop, which was held at IRRI in 1996. This was the first time all scientists
working on allelopathy in rice germplasm had an opportunity to be together to
present views and experiences in this field. Weed control becomes very important
in rice production, especially due to high labour costs in direct seeding of
rice and water competition between rice and other sectors. Allelopathy may offer
one way for rice cultivars to suppress weed growth without affecting the environment.
However, allelopathy as a science is in its cradle and it still has a long way
to go before it will be ready for adoption by farmers.
The workshop emphasised the screening of cultivars for allelopathy and development
of techniques to select for allelopathy at an earlier stage in the breeding
programme. Environmental concern was raised about chemical compounds, which
cause allelopathic effects. The physiological cost of allelopathy was discussed
as the production of allelo-chemicals might require energy from the plants and
use resources that would otherwise be used for grain formation. A study showed
that a hybrid between allelopathic and non-allelopathic cultivars had superior
agronomic characteristics in field tests. Preliminary genetic data indicate
that allelopathic activity in rice is quantitatively inherited. The results
of the research on allelopathy in India, Egypt, Korea, Sri Lanka, etc. were
also reported in this book.
7) Advances in Hybrid Rice Technology
Edited by S.S. Virmani, E.A. Siddiq, and K. Muralidham. IRRI, 1998, 443 pages.
The Proceedings compiled
the 27 papers and country reports presented during the 3rd International Symposium
on Hybrid Rice held from 14 -16 November 1996 in Hyderabad, India. The yield
potentials of high yielding varieties developed after the release of IR8 by
IRRI in 1966 have reached a plateau. This poses a serious challenge to sustainable
increased rice production, especially in Asia. Hybrid rice was developed in
China and its commercial production was started in 1976. The development and
use of hybrid rice have enabled China to increase rice production and, at the
same time, save rice land for agricultural diversification to increase farmers'
incomes. Interest in development and use of hybrid rice, therefore, has increased
in other countries. The development and use of hybrid rice in countries outside
of China, however, are still in the early stage.
The Proceedings are a valuable source of information on the genetic resources
for the development of hybrid rice varieties. Detailed information and quantified
data on yield performance, resistance to major insects and diseases, and grain
quality of several hybrid combinations, CMS lines, restorers developed and/or
identified by IRRI and national programmes in China, India, Vietnam, Philippines,
Malaysia, Korea DPR, Egypt, USA, Brazil, Colombia, Sri Lanka, Japan, Thailand,
and Indonesia were provided. Indirectly, therefore, the Proceedings could greatly
contribute to the exchange of germplasm among the countries.
The Proceedings also provide valuable experiences and insights with regard to
the national policy and the organisation of national programme for successful
development of hybrid rice varieties and their transfer to farmers based on
lessons learnt in China, India, and Vietnam. The information on the technological
tools for and the progress of the development of new generation of hybrid rice
such as 2-line and one-line hybrid in these Proceedings could serve as a solid
scientific base for future works on the development of the parental lines and
hybrids. Technical guidelines for successful and high yield production of seed
of 3-line hybrid varieties could also be drawn based on information provided
in the papers in these Proceedings.
8) Fertilization of Rice in Japan,
Akira Suzuki, 1997, 112 pages.
This book covers the
following topics in rice farming: development of rice production and plant nutrient
supply, development of fertilizer application methods in Japan, maximising the
rice yield, plant nutrient balance sheets under rice cropping systems, and nutrient
management of rice and the environment.
Increasing the food production is a matter of utmost importance in order to
cope with the increasing population pressure of the world. Rice farming in Japan
is performed under irrigation but in different natural and socio-economic environments
than in other parts of the world. Therefore, the first chapter of the book is
devoted to a general description of the conditions of rice cultivation in Japan,
under which fertilisation technologies have been developed.
The exploitation of arable land is limited and raising food production will
inevitably depend on yield increases per unit area. Yield increases are basically
dependent on genetic and natural resources including soil and water. Fertilizer
use ensures that the potential of genetic resources is used to a maximum extent
by replenishing soil resources with necessary nutrients, thus sustaining food
security. A yield exceeding 13 tons per ha is expected from high-yielding plant
types of rice and development is progressing now. As these cultivars are developed,
larger quantities of nutrients must be supplied at the time of plant demand.
Thus, a new fertilisation technique needs to be developed to sustain a quantum
jump in the yield of rice without bringing about soil and water deterioration.
In the context of environmental conservation, Integrated Plant Nutrition Systems
(IPNS) are designed to make optimum use of fertilisers by balancing the nutrients
available to farmers from all sources, including mineral and organic materials.
Technically, problems will be the difficulties encountered in best quantifying
predictions and estimates of the optimal amount of nutrients to be applied in
mineral and/or organic forms under various environments and with different requirements
of cultivars. Studies are being conducted to develop various models for predicting
the growth of rice and the nutrient behaviour in the soil.