PARAGUAY
by Albrecht Glatzle and Dieter Stosiek |
| 5. THE
PASTURE RESOURCE
Table 6: Areas (millions of hectares) of native and cultivated pastures and extensively grazed bush land in Paraguay (Molas et al. 1996)
Native Grazing Resources in Eastern Paraguay. Most of the grazing lands in the Oriental Region are marginal for agriculture due to natural constraints such as poor drainage, shallow soils, and rocky soil . Basically there are two types of native pastures in Eastern Paraguay.
Native Grazing Resources of the Chaco Region. The Occidental (Chaco) Region is an extended alluvial plain with a gradient of rainfall and soil texture from north-west to south-east (more rain and finer texture as the distance from the Andes Mountains increases). The agro-ecological conditions are good for permanent pastures. However cropping faces some limitations and risks from the quantity and distribution of rainfall (Dry Chaco) and temporary waterlogging (Humid Chaco) respectively (Figure 4). The native grazing resources in the two major physiographic sub regions of the Chaco can be described as follows:
Periodically and episodically flooded areas with waters from the Pilcomayo river in regions with rather low rainfall (below 750 mm) are to be considered as a transitional zone between the Humid and the Dry Chaco. This zone along the left side riverbanks of the upper Picomayo-river is exposed to an extremely varying water regime, which may cause seasonally flooded grasslands to be reconverted into xeromorphic bush and vice versa within a few consecutive years. Towards the sub-humid parts of the Central Chaco (south and east), inclusions of edaphic grasslands on poorly drained gleysols (so called water-camps) are found with increasing density. The forage species occurring in the water-camps are essentially those listed for the Copernicia savannas in the Humid Chaco. Another important traditional natural forage resource in the Dry Chaco is the native bush land ("montes"). Browsing the mostly thorny woody plants, such as Acacia praecox, A. aroma, Caesalpinia paraguariensis, Ruprechtia triflora, Capparis tweediana and C. retusa and eating the pods of various Prosopis and Acacia spp. (Morello and Toledo 1959) supports an average stocking density of about one bovine animal unit to 10 to 15 ha of bush (Fretes et al. 1969). Understorey grasses are virtually absent: Setaria globulifera, S. fiebrigii and Digitaria sacchariflora are practically the only grasses found, but in very low frequency. There are studies demonstrating a severe degradation of the "monte" soils due to overgrazing under traditional grazing regimes. However, Adámoli et al. (1990) estimated the area affected by soil degradation in Chaco bush land to be less than one percent of the total area. Abril and Bucher (2001) reported that soil organic carbon losses are much lower under cultivated pastures than in over utilised bush land. |
| 6. OPPORTUNITIES FOR IMPROVEMENT OF FODDER RESOURCES
Sown Pastures with Introduced Forages.
The establishment of pastures with selected grasses and legumes on cleared land raises
herd productivity per unit area about ten fold (Glatzle and Cabrera 1996, and Table 3).
Hence it is not surprising that the area of cultivated pastures increased five to six fold
since 1980, mostly at the expense of native forests and bush. Large scale land clearing
and pasture establishment obviously has adverse effects on landscape and species diversity
and carbon sequestration. Therefore it is indispensable to take into account a number of
land clearing regulations in order to maintain or create a healthy and diverse
agro-ecosystem. A steadily increasing number of farmers leave at least 25 percent of the
forest, woodlands or bush of a property intact (Ley Forestal 422/73). A significantly higher biodiversity was found when pastures contained a large number of
native bush niches (strips and "islands") and when the use of fire as a
management tool was restricted or avoided (Glatzle 1999). Moreover, at sites with an
elevated dry land salinity risk (high water table of saline ground water in a semi-arid
climate, such as the Chaco), native bush fulfils the important role of preventing salinity
due to the very high suction forces produced by many Chaco woody species, capable of
keeping the ground water at a low level (Glatzle et al. 2001). Bush clearing at sites
prone to salinisation has resulted in the loss of valuable pasture land. Pasture establishment in Paraguay with selected forages has a relatively short history
but has reached significant importance during the past two decades (Table 6). Probably
with the introduction and multiplication of buffel grass (Cenchrus ciliaris) by an
American agricultural advisor of the Mennonite colonies in the Central Chaco, Robert
Unruh, in the early nineteen fifties, cultivated pastures attained economic importance for
the first time. Later on, a number of other introduced grasses gained commercial
importance and were multiplied on a national level (Table 7). When the German-Paraguayan
Project "Estación Experimental Chaco Central" started in the early
nineteen-nineties, a new era started for the commercial use of introduced pasture legumes
(Table 7). In order to maintain productivity, cultivated pastures require, even more than native
grazing lands, a correct adjustment of stocking rates. Typical stocking rates range from
about 0.5 to 2 bovine units per hectare along the rainfall gradient across Paraguay, from
north-west to south-east. Maximum energy conversion from Panicum maximum cv. Gatton
and Cynodon nlemfuensis pastures in the Central Chaco by grazing steers (into
animal liveweight per ha) was attained by a stocking rate of 1.8 AU/ ha (Stosiek et al.
1997). This figure exceeds, however, the recommended long term ecological optimum stocking
rate for this zone (0.8 to 1.2 AU/ ha). Maintenance interventions, such as woody weed
control, are necessary to maintain long term profitability of sown pastures. Other grasses cultivated on a commercial scale, but of much less importance than the
ones mentioned in Table 7, are: Chloris gayana cv. Callide, Panicum coloratum
cv. Bambatsi, Brachiaria decumbens, B. mutica, B. humidicola, Cynodon sp.
Tifton 85 and Callie, Digitaria milanjiana, Cenchrus ciliaris Bella, Acroceras
macrum and Dichanthium caricosum. Pasture legumes of secondary importance are: Macroptilium
atropurpureum Siratro, Lotononis bainesii, Stylosanthes scabra cv. Seca and
Siran, S. hamata cv. Amiga, Clitoria ternatea cv. Milgarra and Chamaecrista
rotundifolia cv. Wynn. Other Fodders. Among the most important cultivated forages is Silage Sorghum for
dairy enterprises. In the Central Chaco (accounting for about 50 percent of the national
milk production), the area cultivated with Silage Sorghum is estimated at over 10,000
hectares. At smallholder level in Eastern Paraguay some silage is made from Pennisetum
purpureum (Cameroon grass). Part of the grain Sorghum (23,000 t on 16,000 ha in
Paraguay) and maize (900,000 t on 370,000 ha in Paraguay) is used for concentrates, to be
mixed at farm or at small commercial enterprise level with the agro-industrial by-products
obtained predominantly from oilseeds (Table 5). No statistics are available on total
concentrate feed production, nor on the proportions used to feed dairy cows, pigs, horses
or poultry. However, concentrates used for beef production are negligible. A typical emergency feed is sugar cane, grown on a small area on many farms and
harvested in the dry season. During prolonged drought periods (about one in 10 years),
whole sugar cane (produced in more humid Eastern Paraguay) is sold to cattle farmers in
the Dry Chaco to enable them to maintain at least their breeding herd. There is little
haymaking in Paraguay. Similarly, there is virtually no irrigated fodder production due to Table 7: Commercially important pasture grasses and legumes in Paraguay Botanical name Cultivar or/and common name Importance Cultivated
grasses Panicum maximum Gatton Since 1990 most
important grass for newly cleared lands. In the Chaco, many 100,000 hectare of highly
productive Gatton pastures. Panicum maximum Colonial and
Tanzania Grown on the
more fertile basaltic soils in East Paraguay. Less important in the Chaco. Cenchrus ciliaris Buffel
grass, Texas 4464 Since nineteen
fifties. Several 100,000 ha in the Dry Chaco. Otherwise replaced by Gatton. Cynodon nlemfuensis Estrella Several 100,000
ha along the limit of the Dry and Humid Chaco, in the Humid Chaco, and on the fertile
soils in East Paraguay. Brachiaria brizantha Marandú Wide spread in
East Paraguay predominantly on infertile sandy soils. In the Chaco not frequent. Tolerant
to spittle bug. Digitaria eriantha var. pentzii Pangola Several 10,000
hectare on sandy soils and at shortly inundated sites in East and West Py. Urochloa mosambicensis Nixon Important since
1995 in the Chaco to restore rundown Gatton and buffel pastures. Cultivated
legumes Alysicarpus vaginalis Alyvag Restores
rundown arable regosols in the Chaco. Combines well with Pangola. Also used as a summer
active ley legume. Stylosanthes hippocampoides Oxley Excellent to
restore rundown arable regosols. Combines well with Pangola. Desmanthus virgatus Filadelfia Cultivated
legume, native to the Chaco. Adapts well to heavy textured soils. Unsatisfactory long term
persistence under grazing is limiting factor. Leucaena leucocephala Cunningham
and Tarramba Used as a
fodder bank by an increasing number of smallholders and big farms. Trifolium repens Haifa Winter active,
to be mixed into permanent pastures in the Alto Paraná Valley, East Py. Melilotus alba Sweet clover Winter active
ley legume, relatively rare. Constraints. The main constraints to pasture establishment, grassland
management, forage and ruminant production and product marketing in Paraguay are the
following: Pasture seed production. There is a strong small to medium scale pasture seed
production in the Central Chaco of Paraguay at farm level. The seed produced are Panicum
maxium cv. Gatton, Cenchrus ciliaris cv. Texas 4464 and Bella, Urochloa
mosambicensis, Chloris gayana cv. Callide, selections of Digitaria milanjiana, Panicum
coloratum cv. Bambatsi, Sorghum sudanense, Leucaena leucocephala, Alysicarpus
vaginalis, Desmanthus virgatus cv. Filadelfia and Stylosanthes hippocampoides
cv. Oxley. Total seed production attains several hundred tons a year. Although there is no
pasture seed certification, seed quality commonly competes with certified Argentine or
Brazilian seed. Most seed is locally marketed directly between farms or via the
co-operatives of the zone. Bigger seed producers also export Gatton Panic seed to
neighbouring Argentina and Bolivia. However, practically all Brachiaria spp. seed
and most Panicum maximum cv. Tanzania and cv. Colonial seed which are used in
Paraguay, are imported from Brazil, because seed yields are too low under local
conditions. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 7. RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ORGANIZATIONS AND PERSONNEL
At present little research is carried out actively in Paraguay in the fodder and
pasture sector. However, in the past, international or bilateral programmes and projects
introduced and screened pasture species, initiated trials on pasture and herd handling and
grazing management, and disseminated innovations in the forage and livestock sector. For
example: Besides that, there were many initiatives by individual farmers to
introduce and test species they brought in from other countries, mostly Brazil and
Argentina. Most of the Brachiaria species and a number of Cynodon cultivars
came in through this channel and were spread from farmer to farmer. More recently, livestock farmers interested in applied experimentation
became privately organised in the "Consorcio Ganadero para la Experimentación
Agropecuaria (CEA)". CEA holds a highly appreciated international congress on
technology transfer every year in Asunción at the headquarters of the "Asociación
Rural del Paraguay (ARP)". CEA members even organised an information travel of
farmers to Queensland, Australia, from where a lot of new ideas and aspects on cattle
breeds and grass cultivars came into the country. Moreover, the ARP is the organiser of a
big annual Agricultural Trade Fair, where regularly cattle breeds and adapted pasture seed
are exposed and marketed. On a regional level, farmers conscious of sustainable and
profitable production systems organise themselves in so called CREA-groups
("Consorcio Regional de Extensión Agropecuaria"). Some private CREA groups work
very efficiently, and sometimes contrast favourably with public extension services, such
as divisions of the Ministry based "Dirección de Extensión Agrícola y Ganadera
(DEA)" or even services offered by credit institutes, such as CAH, BNF and Fondo
Gandero. Only about one in ten farms is reached by a pubic extension service at a
nation-wide average (Molas et al. 1996). However, many producers co-operatives
provide competent technical assistance to their members. A new programme has started in October 2001 at Loma Plata, Chaco, the
"Iniciativa para la Investigación y Transferencia de Tecnología Agraria Sostenible
(INTTAS)", initiated by the private foundation DeSdel-Chaco ("Fundación para el
Desarrollo Sostenible del Chaco"), and sponsored by the Swiss foundation AVINA
("Acción para la Vida y la Naturaleza"). This programme integrates,
co-ordinates and complements the on-farm-experimentation and technology dissemination
activities carried out by various co-operatives and their extension services, and private
farmer groups within the Paraguayan Chaco. Furthermore, INTTAS is to reactivate a
virtually paralysed public research station in the Chaco Region, implementing joint
research programmes, and to promote regular exchange of experience with private and public
entities of interest from the other Chaco countries, Argentina and Bolivia. The "Dirección de Investigación Agrícola (DIA)", part of
the Ministry of Agriculture, carries out research mainly in the cropping sector in 9
research stations spread over the country. However, little importance is given to research
in pastures and forages. The mandate of another Ministry-dependent research unit, the
"Dirección de Investigación de Producción Animal (DIPA)", is to conduct
research in the animal production sector in three stations across the country. Again, the
products of co-operative based and other private initiatives on animal breeding, animal
selection and improvement of herd handling are more obvious than public efforts in this
field. The low efficiency of public research in Paraguay is primarily due to the lack of
operational funds. More than 80% of the small budgets available (including revenues
generated on the research stations) are used to cover the personnel costs. In contrast to many other countries throughout Latin America efforts to
revamp public-sector agricultural research and development agencies in Paraguay have yet
to come to fruition. Major change was proposed in the mid-1990s in the form of the
establishment of a national agricultural research institute, the Paraguayan Institute of
Agrarian Technology (IPTA), as a joint public-private venture with multiple funding
sources. The proposal for the creation of IPTA is still pending, however, and it now
appears that no legislative decision will be made until at least 2002, following a public
reform process that is currently underway in Paraguay Beintema et al. (2000). On the other
hand meanwhile, a strong negative selection process is being observed, by skilled
technicians and scientists moving away from the public sector (DIA and DIPA) into private
research and development entities. Some kind of extension work and small scale experimentation in the
forage and livestock sector is done by institutions of higher education which are: Distinguished Technicians currently engaged in public or private
research programmes in the pasture and forage sector are: |
| 8. REFERENCES Abril, A. and E.H. Bucher (2001): Overgrazing and soil carbon dynamics in the western Chaco of Argentina. Applied Soil Ecology 16, 243 - 249 Adámoli, J., E. Sennhauser, J.M. Acero and A. Rescia (1990): Stress and disturbance: Vegetation dynamics in the dry Chaco region of Argentina. Journal of Biogeography 17, 491 - 500 AHK (1999): PARAGUAY. Deutsch-Paraguayische Industrie- und Handelskammer, Asunción, Paraguay Beintema, N.M., P. Zambrano, M. Nuñez, and P.G. Pardey (2000): Agricultural R&D in Paraguay: Policy, Investments, and Institutional Profile. International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington D.C. Bertoni, G.T. and J.R. Gorham (1973): The Geography of Paraguay. In J.R. Gorham (ed.). Paraguay: Ecological Essays. Academy of the Arts and Sciences of the Americas, Miami, pp. 9 - 18 BGR (2001): Proyecto Sistema Ambiental del Chaco. Inventario, evaluación y recomendaciones para la protección de los espacios naturales en la Región Occidental. Bundesanstalt für Geowissenschaften und Rohstoffe, Hannover DCEA (2000): Síntesis Estadística 1999/2000. Dirección de Censos y Estadísticas Agropecuarias, Ministerio de Agricultura y Ganadería, Asunción, Paraguay Degen, R. (1996): Dinámica poblacional de Copernicia alba Morong "Caranday". Dirección de Ordenamiento Ambiental and Estación Experimental Chaco Central (unpublished report) Eidt, R.C. (1969): The climatology of South America. In E.J.J. Illes, H. Klinge, G.H. Schwabe, and H. Sioli (eds.). Biogeography and ecology of South America. Vol. 1. Dr. W. Junk, The Hague FAO (2001): Online Statistical Database. http://apps.fao.org Fatecha, A. (1989): Present and potential area for agricultural use in the Arid Chaco of Paraguay. In M. Hump and M.A. Tiefert (eds.). Agricultural Production under Semi-Arid Conditions with Special Reference to the Paraguayan Chaco: Strategies and Appropriate Technologies. DSE Feldafing, pp. 26-49 Fretes, R., C. Gay and R. Samudio (1969): Las praderas naturales del Paraguay. I. Clasificación y caracterización. Programa Nacional de Investigación y Extensión Ganadera. Publicación No. 6, San Lorenzo Glatzle, A. and A.J.N. Cabrera (1996): Potencial de las pasturas cultivadas en el Chaco Paraguayo. In Consorcio de Ganaderos para Experimentación Agropecuaria (ed.): CEA 96; Forrajes. IIIer Congreso Internacional de Transferencia Tecnológica Agropecuaria (17 y 18 de Nov. 1996), Asunción, 155 - 168 Glatzle, A. (1999): Compendio para el Manejo de Pasturas en el Chaco. Edición El Lector, Asunción, Paraguay Glatzle, A., R. Schultze-Kraft, and R. Mitlöhner (2001): Potential Role of Native Bush in the Chaco for Mitigation of Dryland Salinity in Grassland. XIX International Grassland Congress, February 2001, Piracicaba, Brazil, ID 24-02 Gorham, J.R. (1973): The Paraguayan Chaco and Its Rainfall. In J.R. Gorham (ed.). Paraguay: Ecological Essays. Academy of the Arts and Sciences of the Americas, Miami, U.S.A., pp. 39 - 60 GTZ (1994): PARAGUAY. Perfil del país con informaciones y comentarios relacionados al desarrollo económico y social. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit, Eschborn, Germany Hacker, J.B., A. Glatzle and R. Vanni (1996): Paraguay - a potential source of new pasture legumes for the subtropics. Tropical Grasslands 30, 273 - 281 MAG (1992): Censo Agropecuario Nacional 1991. Ministerio de Agricultura y Ganadería, Asunción, Paraguay MAG (1996): Lineamiento Estratégico para el Desarrollo del Sector Agropecuario y Forestal. Ministerio de Agricultura y Ganadería, Asunción, Paraguay Mereles, F., R. Degen and N. Lopez de Kochalca (1992): Humedales en el Paraguay: Breve reseña de su vegetación. Amazoniana 12, 305 - 316 Molas, O., R. Heyn and R. Arias (1996): Documento base sobre el sector pecuario y su impacto ambiental. ENAPRENA, Asunción, Paraguay Morello, J. and C. Saravia Toledo (1959): El Bosque chaqueño. II. La ganadería y el bosque en el Oriente de Salta. Revista Agronómica del Noroeste Argentino 3 (1-2), 209 - 258 Ramella, I. and R. Spichiger (1989): Interpretación preliminar del medio físico y de la vegetación del Chaco Boreal. Contribución al estudio de la flora de la vegetación del Chaco. Candollea 44, 639 - 680 Ramírez, E.G. and J.L. Laneri (1989): Fodder and Feeding of Cattle in the Paraguayan Chaco. In M. Hump and M.A. Tiefert (eds.). Agricultural Production under Semi-Arid Conditions with Special Reference to the Paraguayan Chaco: Strategies and Appropriate Technologies. DSE Feldafing, pp. 139-148 Sáchez, T.F. (1973): The climate of Paraguay. In J.R. Gorham (ed.). Paraguay: Ecological Essays. Academy of the Arts and Sciences of the Americas, Miami, U.S.A., pp. 33 - 38 Stosiek, D., A. Glatzle and R. Schultze-Kraft (1997): Utilized Metabolizable Energy and Its Impact on the Management of Grass Pastures in the Central Chaco of Paraguay. Proc. XVIIIth International Grassland Congress, Winnipeg and Saskatoon, Canada, 29-7 - 29-8 Tarso Zuquim, P. and I. Lima Serrano (1997): Tuiuiú: Under the skies of the Pantanal. Empresa de Artes, São Paulo, Brazil (work sponsored by Monsanto do Brazil) Verma, G.P. (1982): Research needs for the development and improvement of dryland agriculture in the Paraguayan Chaco. Unpublished report of the Technical and Economic Co-operation between the Government of the Republic of India, New Delhi, India and the Government of the Republic of Paraguay, Asunción, Paraguay World Factbook (2000). CIA World Factbook 2000 - Paraguay. Website < http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/pa.html > |
| 9. CONTACTS Glatzle, Dr. Albrecht Asesor Técnico Administrativo de la Iniciativa para la Investigación y Transferencia de Tecnología Agraria Sostenible (INTTAS) Loma Plata - 1045 / Chaco C.d.c. 883 Asunción PARAGUAY Tel: xx 595 (0)918 3150 Fax: xx 595 (0)918 3050 E-Mail: albrecht.glatzle@inttas.com.py Stosiek, Dieter Agrosys (Systemas Agropecuarios para el Chaco) Filadelfia 578 / Chaco Casilla de Correo 984 Asunción 9300 PARAGUAY Tel: xx 595 (0)91 2132 E-Mail: ds.agrosys@gmx.net [Minor editing of the profile was done by J.M. Suttie and S.G. Reynolds in November 2001]. ------------- |