Regional Workshop on "Trash Fish" in the Asia-Pacific Region
Halong Bay, Viet Nam
6-10 June 2005
 
Background
"Trash Fish" is a broadly used term for fish species that by virtue of their small size or low consumer preference have little or no commercial value. The use of the term "trash fish" varies among States and fisheries and can also change both seasonally and with location. One category of trash fish are those not used for human consumption (either landed or discarded at sea). Those that are landed are often small fish that are targeted for processing into fish/animal meal, for example Japanese anchovy and chub mackerel or fish that have become damaged because of rough handling or due to lack of ice or on-board freezing facilities. The other category is low-value fish used for human consumption. The huge number of small-scale fisheries in the Asia-Pacific region generates a large quantity of this type of trash fish, much of which is consumed or utilized locally as part of household food security, artisanal processing or for small-scale rural aquaculture and livestock raising. Utilization may be extremely efficient with almost no wastage and a lot being converted through drying, fermenting and salting into a wide range of human food products. In countries such as Bangladesh, almost all fish caught is consumed.

The issues relating to the different types of trash fish are diverse though intertwined. One major issue for the region is the increasing demand for trash fish for aquaculture and other animal feeds. Recognizing the potential effects of declines in marine capture fisheries, many governments have turned to aquaculture as a means to increase fish supply, provide employment and generate foreign income. On the one hand, aquaculture development can be seen as a viable option to utilize trash fish yet, on the other hand, it is putting increasing pressure on the already over-exploited fish stocks in the region. Over the last decade, the price of trash fish has risen considerably, and is predicted to increase over the next few years due to increased demand for fish meal and fish oil to meet market demands for aquaculture of carnivorous fish (as well as a source of affordable food). Declining stocks of many trash fish species such as Japanese anchovy, chub mackerel and filefish will aggravate the situation. Given that aquaculture is predicted to grow while capture fisheries remains stable, it will be difficult to meet the demand for trash fish.

Direct feeding of trash fish occurs for some cultured species such as grouper and mud crabs. They are also used as supplemental feeds for other species such as tilapia, prawns and milkfish. Trash fish are also being increasingly used as the raw ingredient in local production of fish meal and fish oil in Asia and the Pacific. The feed milling industry is a major sector in many States of the region with a large number of feed mill factories spread across many States. They produce large quantities of aquaculture, poultry and livestock feeds.

Yet another issue relates to fish landed by larger industrial vessels. These fish are typically landed at a single point (port) and are typically in a poor state of preservation or severely damaged from the capture method. Utilization of this fish is either through conversion into fish meal or direct use for livestock or aquaculture in the general vicinity of the landing site. The question is whether better post-harvest handling and processing will yield a better return for this limited resource.

Another separate but related issue is the capture of juvenile fish of potentially important commercial species (so-called growth over fishing). Trash fish currently constitute about 60 percent of the total trawl catch from the Gulf of Thailand and between 18 and 32 percent of trash fish are juveniles of commercially important fish species. Given a chance to grow to a larger size, these species would provide many more benefits in terms of production, but even more importantly in terms of value.

Goal and objectives
The goal of the workshop was to develop a clearer regional understanding of the status of trash fish production. Participants discussed issues relating to trash fish in the Asia-Pacific region and quantified, to the extent possible, the current trends and status of trash fish. The workshop agreed on strategies to address the identified issues and designed a "Plan of Action" to implement the strategies at national, subregional and regional levels.
Organized by
  • The Asia-Pacific Fishery Commission (APFIC) Secretariat in collaboration with Viet Nam Ministry of Fisheries
  • FAO Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific
Participants
Approximately 30-40 participants from APFIC member countries in the region as well as organizations such as:
  • Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia and the Pacific (NACA)
  • South East Asian Fishery Development Centre (SEAFDEC)
  • WorldFish Center
  • Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research (ACIAR)
  • Support to Marine Aquaculture Project, Viet Nam (MOFI DANIDA)
  • UNEP/GEF South China Seas Project
Outputs
The primary output was a scientific analysis of current trends and status of trash fish in the region. The workshop provided a forum for discussion of the outcomes of the workshop (through meetings among senior fisheries officials) with a view to establishing active cooperation in addressing the issue nationally, regionally and internationally through a mixture of funding sources. This process will also involve media coverage and promotion of the importance of fisheries in the region and the potential threats to future livelihoods and human well-being. Widespread dissemination of the results is intended to improve awareness of these issues.
Contact
Simon Funge-Smith
Aquaculture Officer
FAO Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific
E-mail: FAO-RAP@fao.org