Previous PageTable Of ContentsNext Page


III. Most salient findings


III. Most salient findings

III.1 The rural woman in official statistics

Though official statistics are undeniably deficient in accurately portraying such a complex and indeterminate social phenomenon as the role of women in agriculture, they are critical to framing the quantitative dimensions of the target population group.

III.1.1 The work of the rural woman in the Active Population Survey (APS)

The work of the rural woman in the Active Population Survey (APS)2

Table 1 details the structure of the active Spanish agricultural population by gender in 1991.

TABLE 1: SOCIO-PROFESSIONAL BREAKDOWN OF THE ACTIVE AGRICULTURAL POPULATION BY GENDER

Professional status

Men

Women

Total

 

(× 1000)

%

(× 1000)

%

(× 1000)

%

Employer

29.0

2.35

2.9

0.45

31.9

2.01

Farm operator without hired labour

464.7

42.2

142.4

32.5

607.1

39.39

Cooperative member

3.6

0.27

0.6

0.23

4.2

0.41

Unpaid family member

98.3

8.97

142.4

32.56

240.7

15.57

Wage earner

505.5

45.94

147.5

33.71

653

42.37

Other

3.8

0.27

0.4

0.59

4.2

0.25

TOTAL

1104.9

100.00

436.2

100.00

1541.1

100.00

Source: INK - Active Population Survey - 1991 (own compilation)

According to this survey, most women actively involved in agriculture are wage earners (usually casual labour), unpaid family members (working on the farm of a relative with whom they live) and farm operators without hired labour (a denomination that can give rise to confusion and is comparable to the "holder" of the Agricultural Census).

Table 2 indicates the distribution of the active population by gender, the geographical distribution of women employed in agriculture and their proportion in relation to the other production sectors (per Autonomous Community). Women represent 8% of the total active female population (though with notable deviations from the mean, from 35% in Galicia to 0.13% in Madrid) and 28% of the total active agricultural population (below the Community average of about 35%).

TABLE 2: ACTIVE AGRICULTURAL POPULATION BY AUTONOMOUS COMMUNITY AND GENDER

AUTONOMOUS COMMUNITIES

Total active female population (× 1000)

WOMEN

Total active male population (× 1000)

MEN

   

Agriculture (× 1000)

% of total production sector

 

Agriculture (× 1000)

% of total production sector

ANDALUSIA

806.9

105.2

13.04

1665.2

305.4

18.35

ARAGON

157.7

3.4

2.16

299.9

45.6

15.21

ASTURIAS

152.5

27.1

17.78

265.0

26.9

10.16

BALEARIC ISLANDS

103.5

2.0

1.94

177.3

7.8

4.40

CANARY ISLANDS

220.1

13.7

6.23

371.0

25.6

6.91

CANTABRIA

64.8

7.3

11.27

128.3

12.8

9.98

CASTILLA-LA MANCHA

181.2

9.8

5.41

425.8

83.7

19.66

CASTILLA-LEON

341.6

38.7

11.33

647.7

118.5

18.30

CATALONIA

950.8

15.6

1.65

1582.3

68.1

4.31

C. VALENCIANA

548.6

14.5

2.65

965.7

100.6

10.42

EXTREMADURA

132.1

13.7

10.38

265.2

69.6

26.25

GALICIA

462.2

162.4

35.14

691.6

148.2

21.43

MADRID

659.0

0.8

0.13

1203.4

16.9

1.41

MURCIA

138.6

14.5

10.47

248.6

36.9

14.85

NAVARRA

73.3

0.7

0.96

132.5

13.0

9.82

BASQUE COUNTRY

311.7

5.2

1.67

557.9

15.8

2.84

RIOJA (LA)

32.3

1.6

4.96

67.5

9.3

13.78

TOTAL

5 350.4

436.3

8.16

9722.7

1105.0

11.37

Source INK: Active Population Survey - 1991 (own compilation)

One important characteristic of farm women is their age. Approximately 45 % were over 50 years of age according to the survey, much older than the men.

III.1.2 The rural woman in the Agricultural Census of 1989

The rural woman in the Agricultural Census of 19893

The Agricultural and Population Censuses provide useful information for the topic under study. The information needs to be critically reviewed and compared (as is done later) with sectoral studies using qualitative analytical techniques that alone can provide a more accurate indication of the woman's role in agriculture, and particularly on the family farm.

TABLE 3: CENSUS OF FARM POPULATION BY SOCIO-PROFESSIONAL STATUS

SOCIO-PROFESSIONAL STATUS

MEN

WOMEN

TOTAL

Family workforce:

     

- Holder

1.687.879

530.528

2.218.407

- Spouse

143.672

508.773

652.445

- Other family members

544.097

216.626

760.723

TOTAL FAMILY LABOUR

2.375.648

1.255.927

3.631.575

Wage labour:

     

- Full-time

40.004

2.477

42.481

 

N° of workdays

N° of workdays

 

- Casual labour (*)

42.008.043

12.805.274

54.813.317

Source INK: Agricultural Census 1989 - (Own compilation)

TABLE 4: STRUCTURE OF FARM HOUSEHOLD LABOUR ACCORDING TO SOCIO-PROFESSIONAL STATUS, GENDER AND AGE GROUP

Socio- professional status

Under 25 years (%)

From 25 to 39 years (%)

From 40 to 54 years (%)

From 55 to 65 years (%)

Over 65 years (%)

TOTAL

 

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

1. Holders

0.87

0.93

11.24

10.36

30.79

26.51

30.74

26.92

26.39

35.26

1.687.879

530.528

1.1 Holder heads of farm

0.88

0.89

11.4

9.9

31.4

26.2

31.2

27.7

24.9

35.1

1.601.077

426.090

2. Spouses

0.26

0.76

12.5

15.0

36.3

40.6

30.8

30.2

19.9

13.1

143.672

508.773

2.1 Spouses heads of farm

0.17

0.26

11.6

10.2

37.4

39.3

31.9

36.8

18.7

13.2

50.845

26.664

3. Other family members

30.1

33.2

37.5

32.6

19.4

18.2

7.7

8.5

5.2

7.2

544.097

216.626

3.1 Other family members heads of farm

5.9

3.7

32.5

30.3

37.4

43.5

16.0

16.0

8.0

6.2

84.897

19.305

SOURCE: INK - Agricultural Census 1989 (Own compilation)

TABLE 5: HOLDER HEADS OF FARM BY GENDER AND AGE PER AUTONOMOUS COMMUNITY

Autonomous communities

Under 25 years (%)

From 25 to 39 years (%)

From 40 to 54 years (%)

From 55 to 65 years (%)

Over 65 years (%)

× 1000

(%)of National Total

 

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

Men

Women

ANDALUSIA

1.3

1.9

14.5

15.2

35.5

31.4

30.1

26.0

18.3

25.2

309.6

68.5

19.3

16.07

ARAGON

1.07

0.7

12.4

7.9

30.2

21.8

32.0

26.6

24.1

42.9

82.9

10.1

5.18

2.38

ASTURIAS

0.69

0.47

8.6

7.6

26.4

22.8

31.0

29.4

33.1

39.6

41.0

20.6

2.57

4.48

BALEARIC ISLANDS

0.61

0.49

8.07

8.3

31.1

25.8

32.8

32.1

27.3

33.1

20.6

6.6

1.29

1.55

CANARY ISLANDS

0.75

0.81

10.0

8.7

31.4

27.8

30.2

30.2

27.5

32.3

49.0

18.6

3.07

4.37

CANTABRIA

0.9

0.7

13.1

9.9

28.2

24.0

31.8

32.9

25.8

32.4

20.6

5.8

1.29

1.37

CASTILLA LA MANCHA

0.8

0.9

11.8

11.6

30.6

27.1

31.6

24.2

25.6

36.0

162.2

34.0

10.1

7.99

CASTILLA Y LEON

1.1

0.6

12.4

7.8

28.2

22.8

32.1

30.5

26.0

38.0

179.0

41.9

11.19

9.84

CATALONIA

0.01

0.55

11.85

9.10

31.49

27.47

32.19

30.40

23.66

32.50

87.6

13.4

5.48

3.15

COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA

0.5

0.8

10.1

12.1

34.0

28.6

31.1

25.9

24.0

32.3

199.5

43.3

12.47

10.17

EXTREMADURA

0.9

1.4

12.9

12.0

33.1

26.9

30.9

25.0

22.0

34.4

90.3

18.2

5.65

4.28

GALICIA

0.3

0.4

6.5

6.3

26.6

23.3

31.0

28.5

35.4

41.3

196.5

109.8

12.28

25.78

MADRID

0.6

0.5

7.7

6.2

28.8

24.2

34.2

29.3

28.4

39.7

18.1

4.5

1.14

1.06

MURCIA

1.3

1.7

13.4

16.1

35.7

33.2

30.5

25.8

18.7

23.0

60.7

15.7

3.80

3.69

NAVARRA

0.7

0.4

12.4

6.8

29.0

18.6

30.2

25.0

27.4

49.0

31.3

4.1

1.96

0.97

BASQUE COUNTRY

0.8

0.5

11.3

8.7

28.4

23.9

30.9

29.2

28.4

37.5

29.4

8.0

1.84

1.88

RIOJA (LA)

0.8

0.9

12.8

11.1

33.5

26.2

31.6

26.9

21.1

34.6

22.0

2.1

1.38

0.50

NATIONAL TOTAL

0.88

0.89

11.4

9.9

31.4

26.2

31.2

27.7

24.9

35.1

1 601

426

   

Source: INK - Agricultural Census of 1989 (Own compilation)

Tables 3, 4 and 5 lead us to the following conclusions:

1. Without neglecting the importance of women's casual wage labour in agriculture (an aspect that warrants specific examination), the rural women's contribution is mainly that of a theoretically unremunerated household member (more so than the men's).

2. Women holders and particularly holder/heads of farm are mainly found among the older generations (63% of women holder/heads of farm were over 55 years of age) and in agricultural environments with a large proportion of small farms (Galicia has 26% of all the women holders). Very often farm ownership results from the death of the husband, for instance, and as one means of benefiting from protectionist agrarian policies.

Both the Agricultural Census and other studies reported below clearly indicate that the women's involvement in farm work increases in inverse proportion to size of holding. This situation has led commentators to talk of the "subordinate position of women in family agriculture"4.

3. Though the number of women classified as spouses and holders were similar, the number of spouse "heads of farm" (i.e. responsible for daily farm management) was negligible - for the most part in the older age groups (13% above 65 and 50% above 55) and mainly in Galicia (70% of the total) on small uneconomic holdings.

III.2 Main socio-cultural characteristics of farm women

The survey findings were also examined in terms of the independent socio-economic variables of age and level of education. These are essential to assess accurately the importance of the women's role in family households and how they see the future for the farm and the rural community.

III.2.1 Age

1. The women most active on the smallholding were very often in the older age groups nationally 45% were over 55. This was somewhat below the figure from the Agricultural Census of 1989. The percentage increased considerably in those agricultural environments with the least viable holdings5.

The highest proportions of older farm women were found in the Pyrenees (47%), the Cantabrian Cordillera (41 %) and the Atlantic Coast (39%) which are largely less-favoured regions.

2. In contrast, the agricultural environments with numbers of younger women above the national average (24.5%) were the Sistema Bético (42.8%) and the Andalusian Coast (40.7%)6.

3. The older women tend for the most part to be widows (76%) and are largely titleholders. The married women, who usually function as unpaid family labour, are situated in the 35-55 year age group (47.3%) with those above 55 accounting for 37.6% of the total. Most of the young women are single with 84% below the age of 35.

4. The older women work on the "uneconomic" holdings (32% over 55) and a large percentage of retired women above 65 (26%) continue to work on the farm.

III.2.2 Level of education

This variable is particularly important to understand the differences in attitude and behaviour among the groups studied, and the generation gap that exists in Spanish rural society.

The highest levels of illiteracy are found among women wage labourers and the highest levels of education among women employed in agri-business (Table 6).

If we look exclusively at the 16-24 age group, the percentage of women with post-primary education rises considerably, as do differences in socio-cultural behaviour when compared to the rural women as a whole (Table 7).

The level of education in farm households varies considerably from one region to another. Though, nationally, 36.3% have primary schooling, the proportion rises to 69% in the Ebro Basin, but falls to 24% in the Southern Sub-meseta. The national level of illiteracy of 8.5% in fact varies regionally from 17.4% in Guadalquivir-Genil-Campiñas to only 2% in the Duero Meseta.

There are major differences among the various generation groups and notable differences in levels of formal education. While there are virtually no younger women without schooling, this changes among the 45-year-olds, rising to 14.6% in the 55-65 age group and 17.4% among the over-65s. Similarly, the percentage of younger women (under 35) in farm households with post-primary schooling (39%) is much higher than the overall average (10%).

TABLE 6: LEVEL OF EDUCATION OF WOMEN SURVEYED (%)

Level of education

Family Farms FF

Women wage labourers agriculture WWA

Women wage-earners agri-business WWAI

Cannot read

8

10

3

Can read

46

43

26

Primary school

36

39

58

Post primary school

10

8

13

TOTAL

100%

100%

100%

TABLE 7: SOCIO-CULTURAL COMPARISON OF THE WOMEN SURVEYED (%)

CULTURAL PRACTICES

OVERALL

16-24 AGE GROUP

 

FF

WWA

WWAI

FF

WWA

WWAI

Watch TV daily

74

68

65

84

74

75

Do housework

91

85

70

58

54

41

Read periodicals weekly

9

3

9

16

5

13

Read books weekly

3

5

6

16

9

10

Weekly religious activity

51

20

26

33

13

10

Go to the cinema weekly

3

3

7

8

8

14

Go to bars or cafes weekly

12

26

38

48

52

52

Have been on holiday in the last year

11

9

25

25

14

29

Drive a motor vehicle

18

16

35

28

21

41

Have post-primary education

10

8

13

39

16

21

III.2.3 Women and work on the family farm

The confusion that exists, sometimes in the minds of the women themselves, between domestic and farm work inevitably blurs the distinction between productive and reproductive work, a situation which does not arise with the men's work7. Woman's work is discontinuous, irregular and extremely varied, which makes it difficult for the women themselves and of course for conventional statistics to make an objective evaluation.

An examination of data from holdings affiliated to the National Agrarian Accounts Network8 and specific research9, assessing the type of work carried out by rural women and the time involved, provides a clearer picture and empirically confirms that the woman's work is essential linked to the maintenance and reproduction of the family farm, particularly the very small one.

The research findings on the women's role on the family farm can be classified as follows:

TABLE 9: DOMESTIC AND FARM WORK OF RURAL WOMEN (Hours per day)

ANALYSED AREAS

DOMESTIC WORK (hours per day)

FARM WORK (hours per day)

   

SUMMER

WINTER

GALICIAN INTERIOR

10.1

13.4

10.4

GALICIAN COAST

6.3

9.3

1.0

ANDALUSIAN COAST

16.4

1.2

1.5

ANDALUSIAN INTERIOR

13.8

3.4

0.2

CATALONIA INTERIOR

13.8

3.4

0.2

CATALONIAN COAST

7.7

4.0

4.0

TOTAL

10.0

6.3

3.4

Source: Explotación agraria familiar y trabajo de la mujer: estudio comparativo de Andalucía, Cataluña y Galicia (Women and the family farm: a comparative study of Andalusia, Catalonia and Galicia) - Ma Dolors García Ramón et al in "Mujeres y Sociedad" - Lola G. Luna (comp.) - Barcelona - 1991.

This sectoral research provides a more accurate insight into the role played by women on the family farm than do official statistics. In concrete terms, the agricultural activities in which the women are most heavily involved concern livestock (milking, tending, feeding and cleaning), particularly in the agricultural environments of the Atlantic Coast and the Cantabrian Cordillera (specifically the uneconomic holdings) and in intensive horticulture along the Mediterranean Coast. On a secondary level, the women also play an important role in harvesting in these areas and in the Balearic and Canary Islands. Similarly, they are active in the basic handling of agricultural produce throughout the Cantabrian Coast, in the Duero Meseta and on the Andalusian and Eastern-Catalan Coasts.

The rural woman, whether holder or spouse, is also an important source of (usually casual) agri-business labour in these environments. The national sociological survey found that the women's work in agro-industry mainly involved packaging, grading and product preparation - work that requires little skill and is generally arduous.

Case studies10 on women's work in the Valencian citrus sector depict more accurately the role of women in handling and packaging citrus products. The research highlights the difficult working conditions and the need for considerable flexibility and availability (up to 16-hour days).

In this way the "family member" category is acquiring a wage dimension, particularly among the younger women. This, in turn, is modifying farm household income structure in favour of off-farm revenue and is affecting social relations and perceptions within the rural family. This was also detected in other research work on the multiple activities of farms in the European Community11.

III.2.4 Farm women and the future of the family holding and rural environment

At the time of the survey there was already a clear succession problem on farms in which women were actively involved. Approximately 16.6% of the farms were without a successor, rising to 33% and 32% respectively on the Atlantic Coast and in the Cantabrian Cordillera. In contrast, the highest proportions of farms with a definite successor were found in Guadalquivir-Genil-Campiñas, the Sistemas Bético/Penibético and on the Andalusian Coast.

Though the majority trend is migration from the land, particularly among the young women (only 27% of the women interviewed expressed satisfaction with their professional situation and only 5 % wanted their daughters to work on the farm), at the same time there was a high degree of satisfaction with the rural community. A total of 87% of the women interviewed wanted to remain in their village. This level was relatively uniform throughout, except in the Penibético region where it fell to 77 % (though there were differences among the age groups). Also, 45 % wanted their daughters to remain in the village (Tables 10, 11, 12 and 13).

TABLE 10: MOTHERS WANTING THEIR SONS/DAUGHTERS TO BE FARMERS (%)

AGRICULTURAL ENVIRONMENTS

SONS

DAUGHTERS

Ebro Basin

28.6

8.8

Atlantic Coast

9.4

5.2

Cantabrian Cordillera

6.2

2.1

Pyrenees, Catalan and Somontano Pre-pyrenees

29.2

4.4

Duero Meseta

10.9

3.0

Central Mountains

11.0

3.0

Southern Meseta

11.1

5.2

Sierra Morena Grasslands

9.0

2.6

Extremenduran Plains

11.8

4.1

Guadalquivir

18.1

7.5

Andalusian Coast

18.0

9.9

Sistemas Bético/Penibético

5.4

4.2

Eastern-Catalan Coast

14.9

7.0

Eastern Interior

14.7

4.5

Balearic Islands

24.2

8.8

Canary Islands

7.6

3.1

National Average

14.39

5.2

TABLE 11: MOTHERS WANTING THEIR SONS OR DAUGHTERS TO REMAIN IN THE VILLAGE (%)

AGRICULTURAL ENVIRONMENTS

SONS

DAUGHTERS

Ebro Basin

51.5

58.3

Atlantic Coast

34.6

41.0

Cantabrian Cantábrica

20 1

26.5

Pyrenees, Pre-pyrenees

38.6

54.0

Duero Meseta

10.2

19.8

Central Mountains

33.6

37.4

Southern Meseta

59 8

66.0

Sierra Morena Grasslands

40.6

47.6

Extremenduran Plains

55.3

63.4

Guadalquivir-Genil

46. 9

50. 6

Andalusian Coast

53.5

56.1

Sistemas Bético/Penibético

49.7

48.4

Eastern-Catalan Coast

73.0

75.2

Eastern-Catalan Interior

63.0

68.0

Balearic Islands

55.4

58.0

Canary Islands

44.7

47.4

National Average

45.6

51.1

TABLE 12: RESIDENCE PREFERENCES OF FARM WOMEN ACCORDING TO AGRICULTURAL ENVIRONMENT (%)

AGRICULTURAL ENVIRONMENTS

RESIDENCE PREFERENCE

 

The same village

Another village

In the city

Abroad

Ebro Basin

87.9

1.5

10.6

 

Atlantic Coast

90.7

1.6

7.3

0.5

Cantabrian Cordillera

81.9

3.1

14.0

1.0

Pyrenees, Catalan and Somontano Pre-pyrenees

90.3

0.8

8.7

0.3

Duero Meseta

81.5

1.0

17.0

0.5

Central Mountains

86.0

0.8

13.3

 

Southern Sub-meseta

89.5

3.2

6.7

0.5

Sierra Morena Grasslands

88.8

2.7

8.2

0.3

Extremenduran Plains

84.8

2.6

12.0

0.5

Guadalquivir-Genil-Campiñas

87.0

3.1

9.3

0.5

Andalusian Coast

87.5

5.6

6.9

 

Sistema Penibético

77.2

6.0

16.6

0.3

Eastern-Catalan Coast

93.0

2.6

4.2

0.3

Eastern-Catalan Interior

91.9

3.5

4.2

0.5

Balearic Islands

98.0

0.6

1.1

0.3

Canary Islands

84.0

7.3

7.5

1.3

National Average

87.4

2.9

9.3

0.4

TABLE 13 RESIDENCE PREFERENCES ACCORDING TO AGE GROUP (%)

AGE GROUP

LOCATION

 

Same village

Another village

City

Abroad

< 35 years

74.3

4.5

20.2

0.9

36 to 55 years

90.6

2 8

6.3

0.3

> 55 years

94.0

1.6

4.3

0.1

National average

87.5

2.9

9.3

0.4

Previous PageTop Of PageTable Of ContentsNext Page