CCP: TE 99/3





COMMITTEE ON COMMODITY PROBLEMS

INTERGOVERNMENTAL GROUP ON TEA

Thirteenth Session

Ottawa, Canada, 27-29 September 1999

MEDIUM-TERM OUTLOOK FOR BLACK TEA



Table of Contents


I. INTRODUCTION

1. At its Twelfth Session, the Intergovernmental Group on Tea stressed the importance of analyzing longer-term market prospects in order to determine appropriate strategies to maintain remunerative tea prices, taking into full account the impact of such factors as the macro-economic situation, structural changes in some markets and the impact of international trade agreements.

2. This document contains projections which were based on the most recent data available on black tea production, consumption, trade, and growth in population and income. The projections on production were based on a linear trend analysis for each country for the period 1983-85 to 1993-95 and extrapolations to the year 2005. They were adjusted to reflect policy developments, new and replacement planting and improvements in infrastructure. Consumption was projected from past trends, estimates of population and income growth and the assumption of constant real prices. Where possible, projections for black tea were categorised by orthodox and CTC teas. Stock changes were not considered.

3. The Group is invited to study the projections and identify fundamental issues and challenges that may be faced by the world tea economy as it enters into the next century, particularly those constraining the income of tea producers.

II. PRODUCTION

4. World tea production is projected to increase from the 1993-95 average of 1.97 million tonnes to 2.7 million tonnes in 2005, an annual average growth rate of 2.8 percent. Production in India is estimated at 1.02 million tonnes in 2005, an average annual growth of 2.8 percent from the 1993-95 base. Most of the envisaged production expansion in Sri Lanka should result from recent economic reforms and the national plan for tea production expansion. Production by 2005 is projected to reach 285 000 tonnes, compared to 240 000 tonnes during 1993-95, an annual growth rate of 1.6 percent. Significant growth in production is also projected for other major tea-producing countries. China and Indonesia would increase black tea production from 180 000 tonnes and 105 100 tonnes to 220 000 tonnes and 160 000 tonnes, respectively. Output of tea in Bangladesh would grow only moderately from 49 000 tonnes in 1993-95 to 55 000 tonnes in 2005. Increases in both yields and planted area are likely to continue to support the strong growth in tea production in African countries. Output in Kenya is expected to increase at an average annual rate of 2.8 percent to 300 000 tonnes in 2005. Malawi, Tanzania and Zimbabwe are also expected to increase production significantly. Production and yield of tea produced by small growers in Africa are likely to continue to increase rapidly.

5. Production expansion programmes initiated by major exporting countries have contributed to previous increases in output of black tea in recent years, and the impact of these programmes, particularly as bushes reach optimum production age, may continue. The area harvested of all tea has increased by almost one million hectares since 1961, from 1.4 million hectares to 2.3 million hectares in 1996. The average yield per hectare has increased by over 50 percent during the same period. However, the pressure for the cultivation of food crops continues to increase and it is questionable whether any large scale increases will ensue from now on.

III. CONSUMPTION

6. World black tea consumption is projected to increase from 1.97 million tonnes in 1993-95 to 2.67 million tonnes by 2005, an annual growth rate of 2.8 percent. Developing countries would account for the largest part of the prospective increase, with consumption rising from the 1993-95 average of 1.41 million tonnes to 1.95 million tonnes by 2005, an annual growth rate of 3.0 percent. Black tea consumption in India is projected to continue to rise rapidly, reaching 832 000 tonnes by 2005, an annual growth of 3.2 percent from the base period. In other major markets for black tea such as Pakistan, the Islamic Republic of Iran and Egypt, consumption is projected at 160 000 tonnes, 122 000 tonnes and 90 000 tonnes by 2005, respectively. The reduction of import tariffs and declining prices could have a more pronounced effect on consumption in these countries. The projections also suggest significant increases in black tea consumption in other developing countries, such as Turkey where consumption would grow at an annual average rate of 3.2 percent to 150 000 tonnes.

7. In developed countries, including countries in transition, black tea consumption would increase more moderately by 2.2 percent annually, to 719 000 tonnes in 2005. Consumption in the European Community is projected to increase only slightly in the next decade since higher purchases by France, Germany, Italy and the Netherlands would be largely counterbalanced by a continuing decline in the United Kingdom. Consumption in the United States is projected to increase, though at a relatively slow rate of less than one percent. Since many developed countries impose no, or only slight, restrictions on bulk and packaged black tea imports, the effect of trade liberalisation on their consumption would be negligible. Black tea consumption in the countries of the former USSR is projected to increase from 154 000 tonnes in 1993-95 to 250 000 tonnes in 2005, equivalent to an annual growth rate of 4.5 percent over the period.

IV. IMPORTS

8. Import requirements in 2005 are projected at 1.27 million tonnes, an average annual increase of 2.3 percent from average annual imports in the 1993-95 base period. Import requirements by developing countries would increase more rapidly, by about 3.1 percent annually to reach 626 000 tonnes while import demand in developed countries is projected to increase by about 1.6 percent annually to 642 000 tonnes. In volume terms, the major importers would be the countries of the former USSR (mainly the Russian Federation), Pakistan, the United Kingdom, Egypt and the United States which would account for 51 percent of total import requirements. The average annual growth rate of imports by the former USSR is projected at 2.4 percent though this may have to be revised downward if the current economic crisis continues.

V. EXPORTS

9. Net export availabilities are projected to reach 1.292 million tonnes in 2005, an average annual increase of 2.5 percent from the actual exports of 985 000 tonnes during the base period. China, India, Indonesia, Sri Lanka and Kenya are expected to account for 78 percent of the total projected export availabilities. Bangladesh, Malawi, Tanzania, Turkey and Zimbabwe are also expected to increase export availabilities significantly during the projection period.

10. Most of the increase in the volume of export availabilities would originate in Asia. Exports from India, the world's largest tea producer and consumer are expected to recover from the recent disappointing performance while satisfying growing domestic demand. Projected export availabilities for Sri Lanka, currently the largest exporting country, would grow by 1.6 percent annually to 263 000 tonnes in 2005. China, Indonesia and Bangladesh are also projected to increase export availabilities. China would continue the rapid growth of tea sales from the eighties and early nineties reaching 192 000 tonnes in 2005, while Indonesia and Bangladesh would attain export availabilities of 140 000 tonnes and 32 000 tonnes, respectively.

11. Substantial growth in export availabilities is also projected for African tea exporting countries. The region's total export availabilities are projected to amount to 401 000 tonnes in 2005, an annual increase of 2.8 percent from an average of 295 000 tonnes during 1993-95. Kenya, which currently accounts for 70 percent of African tea exports, would increase its availability from 203 000 tonnes (1993-95 average) to 276 000 tonnes in 2005, an average annual growth rate of 2.8 percent. Malawi, with average shipments of 36 000 tonnes in 1993-95, is expected to increase its exports to 44 000 tonnes in 2005. For the other African countries export availabilities would amount to 30 000 tonnes in 2005.

VI. CONCLUDING REMARKS

12. The projections indicate that by 2005, world black tea production and consumption could almost be in balance at 2.7 million tonnes, representing a growth rate of 2.8 percent for each. Production gains would largely result from higher yields, whereas the rise in consumption would largely be due to population and income growth. Developing countries would account for most of the growth and their share in world consumption would rise by 2 percent over the projections period. However, much will depend on economic development of these countries.

13. More importantly, the projections suggest an imbalance in the international market. The projected surplus of export availabilities over import requirements would be about 24 000 tonnes by 2005 from an almost balanced market in 1993-95. This possible imbalance implies that world market prices would be under downward pressure if there were no additional increases in demand and/or downward adjustments in production.

14. There are several ways of narrowing the trade deficit and improving prices, which the Group is aware of and has attempted to address. The most obvious way is by attempting to expand consumption through promotion. Over the last few years, the major efforts of the Group have been to create awareness of the health benefits of tea drinking and to work out a generic promotion programme that would stimulate consumption of tea. The project on tea and health that has been executed for the Group by the United Kingdom Tea Council comes to an end in December 1999, and the Group will have to decide at this Session on the most effective method of keeping up the momentum.

15. The projected gap between exports and imports could also be further reduced through trade liberalisation, particularly of "retail-packed" teas. The direct impact of the Uruguay Round Agreement on bulk tea imports is small since tariffs imposed by major importing countries are already very low or at zero. However, most of the potential growth markets have high import tariffs on "retail-packed" black tea which have restricted exports to those countries. Any reductions of these tariffs would make it possible to expand the value-added trade, and would offer new opportunities for tea exporting countries.

16. Another obvious means of reducing the gap between export availability and import demand and thereby improving prices is through the rationalisation of production in major exporting countries to relieve the supply pressure on the world tea market.

17. Therefore, given the prospect of downward pressure on prices, the commodity policy for tea for the next decade should largely concentrate on the exploration of possible new and market-orientated approaches.


ANNEX

TABLE 1 -Black Tea : Actual and Projected Production

     
           
 

P R O D U C T I O N

   

Countries / Regions

Actual

Projected

GROWTH RATES

 

1984*

1994*

2005

1984* / 1994*

1994* / 2005

 

Thousand Metric Tons

Percent per year

           

WORLD

1858

1970

2681

0.6

2.8

           

DEVELOPING

1728

1941

2581

1.2

2.6

           

Africa

244

335

457

3.2

2.9

Kenya

128

222

300

5.7

2.8

Malawi

36

36

45

0.0

2.0

Rwanda

9

7

15

-2.5

7.2

Tanzania

16

24

32

4.1

2.6

Zimbabwe

13

14

20

0.7

3.3

Other

42

33

45

-2.4

2.9

           

Latin America

52

65

78

2.3

1.7

Argentina

36

51

54

3.5

0.5

Other

16

14

24

-1.3

5.0

           

Near East

161

175

255

0.8

3.5

Iran

44

53

85

1.9

4.4

Turkey

117

122

170

0.4

3.1

           

Far East

1264

1360

1777

0.7

2.5

Bangladesh

41

49

55

1.8

1.1

China

199

180

220

-1.0

1.8

India

618

749

1015

1.9

2.8

Indonesia

92

105

160

1.3

3.9

Sri Lanka

200

240

285

1.8

1.6

Viet Nam

8

10

20

2.3

6.5

Other

106

27

22

-12.8

-1.8

           

Other developing

7

5

14

-3.3

 
           

Developed

130

28

100

-14.2

12.3

           

Former USSR

120

16

80

-18.2

15.8

Other

10

12

20

1.8

4.8

           
           

* = Averages for 1983-85 and 1993-95

       


TABLE 2 - Black Tea : Actual and Projected Consumption

   
           
   

C O N S U M P T I O N

   

Countries / Regions

Actual

Projected

GROWTH RATES

 

1984*

1994*

2005

1984* / 1994*

1994* / 2005

 

Thousand Metric Tons

Percent per year

           

WORLD

1876

1970

2669

0.5

2.8

           

DEVELOPING

1235

1405

1950

1.3

3.0

           

Africa

75

82

101

0.9

1.9

           

Latin America

18

27

41

4.1

3.9

           

Near East

282

417

584

4.0

3.1

Egypt

70

62

90

-1.2

3.4

Iran

43

85

122

7.1

3.3

Iraq

41

1

54

-31.0

43.7

           

Far East

858

877

1194

0.2

2.8

China

79

77

76

-0.3

-0.1

India

413

590

832

3.6

3.2

Pakistan

87

113

160

2.6

3.2

           

Other developing

2

2

30

0.0

27.9

           

DEVELOPED

641

566

719

-1.2

2.2

           

North America

98

96

105

-0.2

0.8

Canada

19

13

13

-3.7

0.0

U.S.A.

79

83

92

0.5

0.9

           

Europe

265

257

279

-0.3

0.7

EC

222

215

229

-0.3

0.6

UK

165

148

135

-1.1

-0.8

Other Europe

43

42

50

-0.2

1.6

           

Former USSR

218

154

250

-3.4

4.5

           

Oceania

28

21

28

-2.8

2.6

           

Other Developed

32

38

57

1.7

3.8

           
           

* = Averages for 1983-85 and 1993-95

       


TABLE 3 - Tea : International Trade , Actual and Projected

             
                       
     

E X P O R T S

   

I M P O R T S

 

Countries / Regions

Actual

Projected

GROWTH RATES

Actual

Projected

GROWTH RATES

   

1984*

1994*

2005

1984* / 1994*

1994* / 2005

1984*

1994*

2005

1984* / 1994*

1994* / 2005

   

Thousand Metric Tons

   

Thousand Metric Tons

Percent per year

                       

WORLD

 

929

985

1292

0.6

2.5

911

985

1268

0.8

2.3

                       

DEVELOPING

929

985

1292

0.6

2.5

420

447

626

0.6

3.1

                       

Africa

 

197

295

401

4.1

2.8

55

42

50

-2.7

1.6

Kenya

 

106

203

276

6.7

2.8

         

Malawi

 

37

36

44

-0.3

1.8

         

Rwanda

 

9

5

9

-5.7

5.5

         

Tanzania

 

13

20

29

4.4

3.4

         

Zimbabwe

9

9

13

0.0

3.4

         

Other

 

32

23

30

-3.2

2.4

         
                       
                       

Latin America

53

53

55

0.0

0.3

14

15

25

0.7

4.8

Argentina

44

43

42

-0.2

-0.2

         

Other

 

9

10

13

1.1

2.4

 

15

25

 

4.8

                       

Near East

2

17

25

23.9

3.6

238

258

366

0.8

3.2

Egypt

           

71

62

100

-1.3

4.4

Iran

 

1

2

0

7.2

0.0

30

34

37

1.3

0.8

Iraq

           

41

1

54

-31.0

43.7

Turkey

 

1

16

25

32.0

4.1

         

Other

             

162

175

 

0.7

                       

Far East

 

671

613

811

-0.9

2.6

111

131

162

1.7

1.9

Bangladesh

28

27

32

-0.4

1.6

         

China

 

91

103

192

1.2

5.8

         

India

 

213

159

165

-2.9

0.3

         

Indonesia

78

89

140

1.3

4.2

         

Sri Lanka

 

187

222

263

1.7

1.6

         

Pakistan

           

87

113

140

2.6

2.0

Viet Nam

 

11

9

17

-2.0

6.0

         

Other

 

74

4

2

-25.3

-6.1

 

18

22

 

1.8

                       
                       

DEVELOPED

         

491

538

642

0.9

1.6

                       

North America

         

98

96

105

-0.2

0.8

Canada

           

19

13

13

-3.7

0.0

U.S.A.

           

79

83

92

0.5

0.9

                       

Europe

           

265

257

284

-0.3

0.9

EC

           

222

215

234

-0.3

0.8

France

           

9

9

12

0.0

2.6

Germany

         

16

17

32

0.6

5.9

Italy

           

3

5

7

5.2

3.1

Netherlands

         

10

15

16

4.1

0.6

UK

           

165

148

135

-1.1

-0.8

                       

Other Europe

         

43

42

50

-0.2

1.6

                       

Former USSR

         

69

139

180

7.3

2.4

                       

Oceania

           

27

20

28

-3.0

3.1

                       

Other Developed

         

32

27

45

-1.7

4.8

                       
                       

* = Averages for 1983-85 and 1993-95