Free, Prior and Informed Consent: a right between challenges and new spaces for participation
The FAO co-organized side-event at the 25th Session of the UNPFII
The FAO co-organized side-event on FPIC at the 25th Session of the UNPFII
©FAO/Emmanuella Kondo
New York - Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) is a fundamental collective right of Indigenous Peoples. This right is the basis for the implementation of the 2007 UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP): the most significant milestone in the recognition of Indigenous Peoples’ rights.
On the eve of UNDRIP’s 20th anniversary, it is more important than ever to recognize FPIC as the starting point for just and meaningful engagement with Indigenous Peoples. Respecting FPIC is the only way to work together with consent, putting Indigenous Peoples at the centre of the discussion and decision-making. FAO is well aware of this: since 2010, FPIC has been incorporated in its Policy on Indigenous and Tribal Peoples and, since 2015, the Organisation has made FPIC compulsory in any projects that have an impact on Indigenous Peoples.
FPIC safeguards Indigenous Peoples’ rights to lands, territories, resources, knowledge, culture, as well as their participation in decisions that affect them, directly or indirectly. FPIC embodies Indigenous Peoples’ rights to be consulted, to participate, and to set and control development priorities, including in inception, formulation, implementation and monitoring and evaluation of any intervention that affects them.
A transformative side-event at the UNPFII
On 22 April 2026, FAO co-organized a side-event at the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues (UNPFII) to shed light on the importance and recent developments regarding FPIC in global processes. The event was co-organized by the International Indian Treaty Council (IITC), the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) and Land is Life.
Bringing together Indigenous Peoples representatives, experts and UN organizations, this side-event focused on the meaningful participation of Indigenous Peoples in global processes and their right to FPIC. “In recent years, we have seen several processes opening for Indigenous Peoples’ participation. This is the case with the process of recognizing FPIC for Indigenous Peoples in pesticides management and involve Indigenous Peoples in the works of the Commission on Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture (CGRFA). At the same time, the full implementation of FPIC remains a challenge. To co-design a way forward, this year FAO hosted a meeting of the FPIC Donors Task Force", said Anne Brunel, Coordinator of the Global Hub on Indigenous Peoples’ Food and Knowledge Systems and facilitator of the event.
FPIC is indeed a key right of Indigenous Peoples. To use the words of Anexa Alfred Cunningham, Chairperson of the UN Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (EMRIP), “FPIC is essential to the exercise of the self-determination, the protection of territorial integrity, the preservation of cultural integrity and the survival of Indigenous Peoples. We welcome the progress made in certain multilateral process, including pesticides management and the Commission of Genetic Resource for Food and Agriculture. These examples demonstrates that when Indigenous Peoples participate meaningfully from the outset, policies become more legitimate, inclusive and sustainable.”
Nevertheless, FPIC implementation is still facing challenges both at global and national level. Sheryl Lightfoot, Vice-chair of EMRIP, reminded that “the most consistent finding from the Rome meeting of the FPIC Donors Task Force was that FPIC is being systematically reduced to consultation. After more than a decade of normative progress, the gap between what the frameworks say and what Indigenous Peoples experience on the ground remains wide".
The right to FPIC is enshrined in the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP). The Declaration is very clear about what this right means, and it should be upheld as one of the main normative tools for its implementation. Francisco Calí Tzay, former UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, reminded that “we must implement and to make our own the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. One of the problems is that we are not using the UNDRIP as the basic defence of our rights. If we start using the Declaration daily, there will no more doubt for any actor on whether the Declaration is binding or not binding".
The right to FPIC enshrined in the UNDRIP applies globally to Indigenous Peoples, but its implementation must consider the specific governance and decision-making systems of every People. Luisa Castaneda, Executive Director of Land is Life, highlighted that many Indigenous Peoples have “created FPIC protocols within their territories, in a participatory way, developing them based on their own governance systems. What we need now is that governments, UN entities, companies and other multilateral organizations respect these protocols, because these are self-determined decisions made by the Indigenous Peoples.” When working with Indigenous Peoples, it is fundamental that all actors respect their customary laws, practices and governance systems. As was put by Sandra del Pino, from PAHO, “it is necessary to work hand in hand with Indigenous Peoples to address all the inequities and inequalities that unfortunately they continue to face. This is why our strategies at PAHO are developed in collaboration with Indigenous Peoples’ leaders".
Participation of Indigenous Peoples in the processes that affect their lives (positively or negatively) must be ensured. This was highlighted also by Carol Zavaleta, Co-Chair of IPON, that reminded her participation in the 20th Session of the Commission on Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture. “We, as Indigenous Peoples representatives, delivered a statement. We mentioned that we would like to see more Indigenous Peoples present in those meetings, since those conversations are very relevant for the health of Indigenous Peoples, but also for their rights and for their lives.”
On a parallel process, Indigenous Peoples’ participation must be ensured also in the pesticides management. Andrea Carmen, Executive Director of the International Indian Treaty Council (IITC), reminded the long process that took to recognize the impact of harmful chemicals on Indigenous Peoples. “The article 29 of UNDRIP says that states shall take effective measures to ensure that no storage or disposal of hazardous materials shall take place in the lands or territories of Indigenous Peoples without their Free, Prior and Informed Consent. We have fought for this for many years. Now it is important that the Indigenous Peoples’ right to FPIC is included also in the International Code of Conduct on Pesticides Management (ICCPM).”
Opening spaces for Indigenous Peoples participation in global policy processes had not been easy. They have too often been excluded. But a glimmer of hope for a change in this respect. Yon Fernández de Larrinoa, head of the FAO Indigenous Peoples Unit, reminded that “we are seeing something new: in some technical committees spaces are being opened to discuss Indigenous Peoples’ issues. This was not the case just a few years ago. It is the first time this is happening. There are now these opportunities with the ICCPM and the CGRFA. We have to make the best of these opportunities. But not only. In 2027 the Committee on World Food Security (CFS) will discuss Indigenous Peoples’ food and knowledge systems. It will be the first time in the history of FAO. This is history that is being written before our very eyes.”