Mr. lgnacio Arnal presented the agenda which was slightly rearranged and adopted.
Mr. A. M. Nour, in the absence of Mr. Gomes (Portugal), facal point on nutrition, presented the report on relevant proposed activities for 1995 and onwards programme which were elaborated in the experts meeting held in Malta, Feb.1994. After discussing and reviewing, the document was adopted with minor modification.
Concerning the venue of the training course (1995), titled "Advanced level regional training course on aquaculture nutrition and feed technology (Finifish and crustaceans), Mr. Nour informed the meeting that Alexandria University accepted to organize this training course and FAO Near East Regional Office accepted to provide technical and financial support.
Mr. Belkhir, in the absence of the focal point on pathology (Mr.C. Agius - Malta), introduced the relevant proposed activities elaborated by the experts meeting held in Malta, Feb. 1994. After discussion, all activities were adopted and appended.
Mr.G. Georgiou (Cyprus), the focal point on Diversification of Aquaculture Production, presented the relevant activities proposed for 1995 and onwards programme which were elaborated in the experts meeting held in Cyprus, April 1994.
After discussing and reviewing the activities, the document was adopted with slight modification.
Mr. A. M. Nour, in the absence of the focal point on Fresh Water Culture (Mr. Mueen - Syria), presented the relevant activities proposed for 1995 and onwards programme, which were elaborated in the Seminar held in Syria, May 1994.
The content was, generally, adopted with the exception of the following activities that were reported for onwards:
Advanced Training Course on Fish Farm Management, including Fish Health Management and Aquaculture Engineering (1996).
Advanced Training Course on Aquatic Ecosystem Management, including Fisheries in national waters (reservoirs, ponds, lakes, rivers,etc.) (1997).
In addition, the Advanced Training Course on the Reproduction of Warm Fish : Cyprinids, Sturgeons, and Catfishes (1995), was changed to cover only the sturgeons (reproduction and growth).
Also, some amendments were brought to the collaborative research activity, titled : “Ecological Studies on natural freshwaters in order to improve fisheries and aquaculture production” (1995–97); the new proposed activity is : "Artificial water bodies management". The objective is ton develop management methods and techniques in order to utilise efficiently artificial fresh water bodies of multiple uses (drinking, irrigation, finfish production, etc…).
Conclusions and Recommendations of the TECAM working group meeting
The TECAM Working Group Meeting recommended the following :
The establishment of data banks for each of the four activities of the TECAM Network is a very high priority for the development of the sector and that should be undertaken through SIPAM.
The publication of a newsletter in order to exchange information between all network members. This could be integrated in the SIPAM Newsletter.
The implementation of E. Mail among network members is highly recommended in order to facilitate quick exchange of information.
The initiation of action to implement the collaborative research which costitute common interest.
1995 should be the starting year and focal points are asked towards this implementation, to identify specific requirements (specialised institutions and skills that are concerned by the Collaborative Research programme).
There is a need to point out that each focal point should act in close cooperation with TECAM Coordinator.
CIHEAM, as a Coordinating institution, should seek external funding for cooperative research programme.
The involvement of young scientists and post-graduate students in the activities of TECAM and especially in the collaborative research ones.
The initiation of actions to realise the relevant activities hereunder proposed at two levels of priority :
6.1. High level of priority
- Pathology:
"General Desease Interpretation and Control Short Course"
The objective would be to produce personnel capable of training people within their country at field level.
The venue will be identified with Malta focal point on Pathology in concertation with TECAM coordinating institution, between Spain, Greece, Italy or France according to their interest and availability.
Tentative costs : 25.000–30.000 USD to cover partly the participants' fees and organisation. Interested member should cover their delegates' fees.
- Freshwater Culture :
“Advanced Training Course on Recent Advances in Tilapia Culture”.
The objective is to national expertise by training trainers.
The venue is foreseen in Egypt for a duration of 2 weeks during April 1995. Alexandria University accepted to organise the activity and to investigate funds covering total or partial implementation (Mr. A. Nour's saying).
Tentative costs : are foreseen 30.000 to 40.000 USD to cover partly or totally participants' fees and organisation. Interested members will be charged their delegates participation fees.
- Diversification of Aquaculture Production:
“Workshop on Marine Finish Diversification in Aquaculture".
The objective is to review the status of knowledge on the culture of new marine finfish species.
The foreseen date is June 1995 and the venue will be identified, in concertation with TECAM coordinator by the Cyprus focal point on diversification between Greece, Spain, Italy or any TECAM member active in this field. The duration will concern 3 days.
Tentative costs : are evaluated to 30.000 USD to cover partly or totally some participants' fees and organisation. Interested member will be charged their respective delegates' participation fees.
- Nutrition:
“Advanced Level Regional Training Course on Aquaculture Nutrition and Feed Technology : Finfish and Crustaceans”.
The objective is to strengthen national expertise by training trainers.
The venue is Egypt and date is foreseen on October 1995 for a period of 2 weeks.
Tentative costs : estimated from 40.000 to 50.000 USD covering totally or partially some participants organisation fees (travel and DSA). Alexandria University accepted to organise this training course and FAO representative of the Near East region accepted to support substantially in its implementation (travel and DSA of lecturers and some participants), (Mr. A. Nour's saying).
- Nutrition :
“Working Group meeting on Methodolgical approaches to fish nutrient research, including quality control criteria for fish feeds”.
The objective is to develop a standard methodology for conducting fish nutrition and feed technology related research activities.
Tentative costs : are estimated to 20.000–25.000 USD to cover experts' particular fees (travel and DSA) and also publication of the results. The proposed date is on November 1995 and period will cover 3 days.
The venue will be identified by the Portugal focal point on nutrition in concertation with the TECAM network coordinating institution.
6.2 Second level of priority
- Pathology:
"Short Course on Diagnostic Bacteriological Techniques"
Tentative costs : 25.000–30.000 USD
- Diversification:
“Advanced Training Course: Injob Training in the Management and Operation of Offshore Cages"
Tentative costs : to be covered by participants belonging to private sector.
- Freshwater Culture :
“Working Groups on Methodological Approaches and Guidelines of Freshwater Fish Culture Management“.
Tentative costs : 20.000–25.000 USD
6.3 1996 and Onwards Priorities
- Diversification:
“Advanced Training Course on Techniques of Fry Production of New Marine Finfish”.
Tentative costs : 20.000 USD
Land-based systems such as onshore installations and marshlands
Tentative costs: 30.000 USD
- Freshwater Culture :
“Advanced Training on Reproduction and Culture of Sturgeons"
Tentative costs :35.000–40.000 USD
Concerning the consultants' report on Reference Centres on Pathology further investigation should be made by the focal point in close cooperation with TECAM Coordinator to identify existing centres as in France, Italy, U.K., U.S.A…which can help the purpose.
The Working Group Meeting held on June 94 in Saragossa - Spain, proposed the following activities for TECAM network programme :
| A- | Prioritized Activities (1995) | |||
| 1 • | Training Course (1995) : Advanced level regional training course on aquaculture nutrition and feed technology : finfish and crustaceans: | |||
| Objective | : | to strengthen national expertise by training trainers. | ||
| Participants profile | : | university degree graduate with working experience in aquaculture nutrition. | ||
| Duration | : | 2 weeks. | ||
| Contents | : | nutrient requirements, nutrient sources, feed composition, feed formulation, feed manufacture, feeding methods, semi-intensive feeding methods, methodological approaches to nutrition research. | ||
| Nb. of participants | : | 15 from Mediterranean region and others from Near East Region (maximum global members : 30) | ||
| Tentative costs | : | 40.000 to 50.000 USD (travel and DSA). | ||
| Venue | : | Alexandria University which accepted to organise this activity and FAO representative of the Near East region accepted to support substantially in its implementation (travel and DSA of lecturers/and some participants). | ||
| 2 • | Working Group (1995) : Methodological approaches to fish nutrition research, including quality control criteria for fish feeds: | |||
| Objective | : | To develop a standard methodology for conducting fish nutrition and feed technology related research activities. | ||
| Participants profile | : | Experts in the following selected key areas that could be combined according to skills: | ||
| • | fish feed technology; | |||
| • | fish feed quality control; | |||
| • | aquaculture products control; | |||
| • | growth, digestibility and experimental design; | |||
| • | nutrients requirements methodology; | |||
| • | water management and quality criteria; | |||
| • | fish feed formulation methodology; | |||
| • | live food production and enrichment techniques. | |||
| • | quality of biological material to be used in experimentation. | |||
| Duration | : | 3 days. | ||
| Nb. of experts | : | 8 to 10. | ||
| Tentative costs | : | 20 000 to 25 000 USD (travel, DSA and publications). | ||
| Venue | : | Portugal, France, Spain or Tunis according to their interest and availability. | ||
| B- | Suggested Collaborative Research (1995–1997) | |||
| 1 • | Development o improved Hatchery Feeding Strategies: | |||
The objective of this research activity would be to develop simple and inexpensive live and dry food-based hatchery feeding strategies for the mass production of selected marine finfish species using locally available agricultural resources. Particular emphasis will be place on trying to simplify existing hatchery feeding methods and reducing fry production costs through improved live and artificial feeds management techniques. The feeding trials should be conducted in parallel within the participating institutions and carried out under similar on-farm conditions within existing marine fish hatcheries.
| Institution profile | : | Institutions actively engaged in the development of larval feeding methods for marine finfish (seabass, seabream). |
| Duration | : | 3 years. |
| Tentative costs | : | to be shared between the participating institutions with respect to running costs at national level and 30, 000 USD covered by the TECAM Network to facilitate staff exchange and periodic assessment meetings. |
| Expected output | : | development of improved low-cost hatchery feeding strategies for selected marine finfish within the participating institutions; publication of the results of the hatchery feeding trials as technical papers for distribution by the focal point within target TECAM Network. |
| 2 • | Development of Improved Intensive Complete Diet Feeding Strategies: | ||
| Objective | : | The objective of this research activity would be to develop economic grow out feeding regimes (based on the use of complete diets) for the intensive culture of finish in tanks of net cages, with particular emphasis given to the use of locally available feedstuffs (including fishmeal replacers) and developing feeding strategies aimed at maximizing fish growth and minimizing feed waste and water pollution. The feeding trials should be conducted in parallel within the participating institutions and carried out under similar on-farm conditions within existing marine fish farms. | |
| Institution profile | : | Institutions actively engaged in the development of larval feeding methods for marine finfish (seabass, seabream) | |
| Duration | : | 3 years | |
| Tentative costs | : | To be shared between the participating institutions with respect to running costs at national level and 30, 000 USD covered by the TECAM Network to facilitate staff exchange and periodic assessment meetings. | |
| Expected output | : | Development of improved economic grow-out feeding strategies for selected marine finfish within participating institutions. Publication of the results of the feeding trials as technical papers for distribution by the focal point within the target TECAM Network. | |
C- Other Related Activities
It was unanimously agreed that the establishment of an aquaculture nutrition and feeding database was a very high priority for the development of the sector and that this activity should be undertaken in collaboration with SIPAM. In this respect it was strongly felt that the nutrition focal point should be consulted for the development of the nutritional database.
D- Suggested Long-Term Activities
These activities are cited hereunder for consideration according to existing and available resources.
Regional Aquaculture Symposium for Mediterranean Countries (in which the nutrition focal point could present results and experiences). It was proposed that these activities could be combined or integrated in Bordeaux or Verona Aquaculture Exhibitions.
The possibility of conducting nutritional research on alternative finfishes and crustaceans.
Workshop on larval feeding techniques for marine finfish.
Development of improved processing techniques for the production of local fish meals and available agricultural by-products.
Aquaculture feeding profiles for marine finfish farms.
Specific training programmes on feeding techniques and technology such as compound feed manufacture, quality control, nutritional fish pathology, unconventional feed sources, etc…
| A- | Prioritised Activities (1995) | ||
| 1 • | General Disease Interpretation and control Short course (1995) | ||
| Duration | : | 1 week | |
| Participants | : | At least one from each interested member (maximum 10) | |
| Terms of reference | : | Participants must have ideally been involved in general fish disease diagnose and control on a regular basis in their respective countries. | |
| An additional objective of this course would be to produce personnel capable of training people within their country at field level. | |||
| Venue | : | Spain, Greece, Italy or France according to their interest and availability | |
| Tentative costs | : | 20, 000–30, 000 (travel+DSA) | |
| 2 • | Short Course on Diagnostic Bacteriological Techniques (1995) | ||
| Duration | : | 1 week | |
| Participants | : | 1 from each interested member (Maximum 7) | |
| Terms of reference | : | Personnel directly involved in laboratory diagnostic work in bacteriology. | |
| Venue | : | France expressed its interest to host and organise this short course | |
| Tentative costs | : | 25, 000–30,000 USD | |
| B- | Suggested Joint Research (1995–1997) | ||
| 1 • | Winter Syndrome of Sea Bream Possible Participating laboratories : Malta, Cyprus, Tunisia, Portugal, Italy, Croatia, Greece, Spain or Egypt according to their interest and availability. | ||
| Objective | : | To study various aspects of the disease such as environmental conditions that could precipitate the disease : histopathology, pathogen isolation, possible links to nutritional deficiencies, etc… with each party concentrating on a specific aspect. | |
| 2 • | Viral Disease Studies Possible participating laboratories:!Malta, Cyprus, Tunisia, Morocco, France, Portugal, Spain, Egypt, Italy or Greece according to their interest and availability. | ||
| Objective | : | To investigate viral fish diseases which are of commercial significance to Mediterranean aquaculture with the various laboratories sharing the responsibilities. | |
| C- | Other Related Activities | ||
| 1 • | Newsletter | ||
| Start at 6 monthly intervals and reduce to quarterly intervals if desirable. This would be integrated with the SIPAM Network. | |||
| 2 • | Review Publication in Mediterranean Fish Diseases | ||
| It was recommended to ask assistance for the organisation of a specific session on Mediterranean fish diseases in a meeting associated with an established activity e.g. EAFP meeting and publish these proceedings. | |||
| 3 • | Legislative control Activity | ||
| Expert report or workshop as indicated above. This would be integrated with the SELAM Network. | |||
| 4 • | Consultants' Report on Reference Centres | ||
| It is estimated that a consultancy of two man-months is required for the implementation of this activity (see TECAM Expert Meeting, Malta, 1994. Conclusions and recommendations). | |||
The level of development and interest in the eventual application of the technology differs considerably between the various countries. However, in general terms the species identified in the Malta workshop continue to carry high priority whilst some new species seem to also have come to the fore in the interim period. These principally include:
| Seriola dumerilii | amberjacks |
| Epinephelus sp. | groupers |
| Thunnus sp. | tunas |
The Zaragoza Working group meeting of experts agreed to recommend the Following:
| A- | Prioritised Activities | ||||||
| 1 • | Workshop : Marine Fishfish Species Diversification in Aquaculture (1995) | ||||||
| Objective | : | To review the status of knowledge on the culture of new marine finfish species. | |||||
| Participants profile | : | Experts and researchers, working in the field. | |||||
| Nb. of participants | : | Maximum 15, to be selected according to their research results. | |||||
| Duration | : | 3 days. | |||||
| Tentative costs | : | 30, 000 USD | |||||
| Venue | : | Greece, Spain, italy or any TECAM member active in this field. | |||||
| Expected output | : | To enable institutions to keep abreast of developments in the culture of new species and to plan future strategies. | |||||
| 2 • | Advanced Training course (1995): Injob Training in the Technical management of Offshore Cages | ||||||
| Objective | : | To strengthen national expertise in the operation and Management of offshore installations by training t rainers. | |||||
| Participants profile | : | Trainers in countries practising this form of aquaculture. | |||||
| Nb.of participants | : | 6 | |||||
| Duration | : | 1 week | |||||
| Venue | : | Spain, Cyprus, Malta or any TECAM member with the capability and willingness to organise such a course. | |||||
| Tentative costs | : | Will be charged on each participant. | |||||
| Expected output | : | Upgrading of the human resource sector in offshore fish farm management. | |||||
| 3 • | Advanced Training course (1996):Techniques of fry Production of new marine Finfish | ||||||
| Objective | : | To Strengthen national expertise in the technology of culture of new species as this becomes available through the colaborative programmes and elsewhere by training trainers. | |||||
| Participants profile | : | Qualified technical managers. | |||||
| Nb. of participants | : | Maximum 10. | |||||
| Duration | : | 5 days. | |||||
| Frequency | : | Biannually e.g. | 1st course | : | Puntazzo puntazzo | ||
| 2nd course | : | Dentex dentex | |||||
| Tentative costs | : | 20, 000 USD | |||||
| Venue | : | Greece, Morocco, Cyprus, Spain or any TECAM member with the capability and wilingeness to organise such a course. | |||||
| Expected output | : | To strengthen the human resource capability in the application of new species culture technology. | |||||
| 4 • | Workshop Management of aquculture Systems | ||||||
| a) | Offshore cages | ||||||
| b) | Land-based systems such as onshore installations and marshlands (1996) | ||||||
| Objective | : | To review the status of aquaculture system development and management which should help to identify ways of cutting production costs. | |||||
| Participants profile | : | Experts and researchers. | |||||
| Nb. of Participants | : | Maximum 15 | |||||
| Duration | : | 4 days. | |||||
| Venue | : | France, Portugal, Spain, Egypt or any institution active in this field. | |||||
| Tentative costs | : | 30, 000 USD. | |||||
| Expected output | : | To enable institutions to keep abreast of new developments of culture systems and to plan future research strategies. | |||||
| B- | Collaborative Research Programme (1995–1997) | ||||||
| 1 • | Development of New Species Technology | ||||||
| Objective | : | To develop new species technology with maximal use of existing resources. It is recommended to establish joint research and development programmes between institutions with an interest in a particular species. This should also aim to exchange biological material. | |||||
| Institution profile | : | Institutions actively engaged in the development of new species technology. This should be identified by the focal point in collaboration with the TECAM coordinating unit. | |||||
| Duration | : | 3 Years. | |||||
| Tentative costs | : | To be shared between the participating institution with respect to running costs at national level and 30, 000 USD to be covered by the TECAM network to facilitate Staff exchange and periodic assessment meetings. | |||||
| Expected output | : | Development of culture technology for an increasing number of species and rapid dissemination of such information. | |||||
| C- | Other Related Activities (1995–1997) | ||||||
| Compilation of existing data on the biology and culture of marine species with aquaculture potential (1995–1997). | |||||||
| Objective | : | To collate the sparsely distributed information on this discipline it was agreed that a compilation of the existing data on the subject is needed. | |||||
One way to progress that was identified would be to ask each species research group as suggested in proposal B.1 to write the relevant section on the appropriate species and then for the focal point to put them together for distribution.
The prioritised activities presented hereunder were recommended by the Zaragoza working group meeting:
| A- | Advanced training courses on : | |||
| 1 • | Recent advances in Tilapia culture (1995) | |||
| Objective | : | To strengthen national expertise by training trainers | ||
| Contents | : | a) | breeding and genetic improvements; | |
| b) | ecosystem; | |||
| c) | fertilisation and artificial feeding; | |||
| d) | requirements and feeding regimes; | |||
| e) | reproduction; | |||
| f) | disease control; | |||
| g) | marketing. | |||
| Duration | : | 2 weeks | ||
| Participants profile | : | University degree in agriculture with 2–3 years experience in aquaculture activities. | ||
| Number of participants | : | 10 – 15 | ||
| Tentative Costs | : | 30.000 – 40.000 USD (travel and DSA) | ||
| Venue | : | Alexandria University accepted to organise the activity and to investigate funds covering total or partial implementations | ||
| 2 • | Reproduction and culture of sturgeon (1995) | |||
| Objective | : | to improve the knowledge of national experts in the field of reproduction and culture of the sturgeons as new species for culture in the Mediterranean. | ||
| Contents | : | a) | artificial reproduction and hatchery techniques; | |
| b) | larval rearing and fingerling production in ponds; | |||
| c) | grow out; | |||
| d) | broodstock management; | |||
| e) | theoretical and applied genetics of these fishes. | |||
| Duration | : | 2 weeks in May – 1995 | ||
| Nb. of participants | : | 10 – 15 | ||
| Participants profile | : | University degree in agriculture with 2–3 years experience in aquaculture activities. | ||
| Tentative costs | : | 35,000 – 40,000 USD. | ||
| Venue | : | Fish culture research institute, Hungary. | ||
| B- | Working Group (1995) | |||
| 1 • | Methodological approaches and guidelines of fresh water fish culture management; | |||
| Objective | : | To develop a standard methodology of management freshwater fish farming. | ||
| Participants profile | : | Experts in different activities of aquaculture management. | ||
| Duration | : | 3 days. | ||
| Nb. of participants | : | 8 – 10. | ||
| Tentative costs | : | 20,000 – 25,000 (travel, DSA and publication). | ||
| Venue | : | Morocco, Libya, Syria or Egypt according to their interest and availability. | ||
| C- | Collaborative Research programmes (1995–1997). | |||
| 1 • | Improving Tilapia culture (Ponds, resevoirs, closed systems). | |||
| Objective | : | The objective of this research activity would be to develop the methods used for tilapia culture which include improving genetics and management (ecosystem, hatching, feeding handling techniques, etc…). | ||
| Participating Institutions | : | All institutes are requested to cooperate according to their interest and experience. | ||
| Duration | : | 3 years | ||
| Tentative costs | : | To be shared between the participating institutions with respect to running costs at national level and USD 50,000 covered by the TECAM Network to facilitate staff exchange, information flows and periodic assessment meetings. | ||
| Expected output | : | Improve Tilapia production from aquaculture. | ||
| Publications | : | The results obtained from the proposed projects will published as technical papers and will be available for distribution by the focal point within the target of the TECAM Network. | ||
| 2 • | Development of the production technology for new species of the fresh water aquaculture in the Mediterranean | |||
| Objectives | : | To elaborate new technologies for artificial reproduction, larval rearing and pond culture of new species, perspectives for the region. | ||
| Participating institutions | : | All interested institutions of the region. | ||
| Duration | : | 3 years | ||
| Tentative costs | : | To be shared between the participating institutes with respect to running costs at national level and USD 50,000 covered by the TECAM Network to facilitate staff exchange, information flows and periodic assessment meetings. | ||
| Expected output | : | Improve production of fish species newly involved into the aquaculture sector. | ||
| Publications | : | The results obtained form the proposed projects will be published as technical papers and will be available for distribution by the focal point within the target of the TECAM Network. | ||
| 3 • | Artificial water body management | |||
| Objective | : | To develop management methods and techniques in order to utilise efficiently artificial water bodies for multiple uses (drinking, irrigation, etc.) for fish production. | ||
| Participating institutions | : | All interested institutions of the region. | ||
| Duration | : | 3years | ||
| Tentative costs | : | To be shared between the participating institutions with respect to running costs at national level and 50,000 USD covered by the TECAM Network to facilitate staff exchange, information flows and periodic assessment meetings. | ||
| Expected output | : | Improving fish production form recently underexploited waters. | ||
| Publications | : | The results obtained from the proposed projects will be published as technical papers and will be available for distribution by the focal point within the target of the TECAM Network | ||