|
Extension Services for Quality Milk Production
Proceedings of an International Workshop in conjunction with the East-West-Forum of the Federal Ministry for Food, Agriculture and Forestry and the "Window of German Animal Breeding" at the International Green Week
24-25 January, 1999
Extension Service and Quality of Milk in Slovenia
M. Klopcic and F. Habe - University of Ljubljana
Slovenia has about 2 million inhabitants and 785 434 ha of agricultural
land - of which 63 % are grassland and pastures. Therefore the cattle production
plays a dominant role in our animal production with 60 % of its income.
Milk production is expanded all over the territory of Slovenia. There were
485 535 cattle, of which 220 000 were cows and heifers and 125 000 cows
with milk recorded production in 1997.
The average farm size in Slovenia is five times smaller than in Europe
and has even been diminishing. Slovenia has one of the worst farm structures
in Europe averaging 4.1 ha of agricultural land per farm (SLS, 1997). In
Slovenia production orientation and market competence of most of the farms
are poor as well as total farm income (4.4 ha of agricultural land per
full time work force, which is four times under the European average; Erjavec,
1995). Unfavourable land owning structure is the cause of small and economically
unsuitable herd size.
The percentage of animal production has come to 50 % in the total value
of agricultural production. Cattle production is the most favourable production
orientation of the Slovene farms. According to the census of 1991 the cattle
were kept on 52 % of farms and cows on 45 % of farms. Simmental breed was
prevailing. More than 60 % of all inseminations were with Simmental bulls
in 1997. The Simmental breed was followed by the Brown breed (18.5 % of
all inseminations) and the Black-and-White breed (12.9 %). The percentage
of Black-and-White cows has been increasing. The percentage of cows that
were inseminated by meat breeds increased, too (in 1997 about 7.8 %). Milk
production prevailed on family farms with cattle production. Despite the
loss of Yugoslav market in which Slovenia sold milk surpluses, during the
transition period from 1990 till today, Slovenia did not diminish the number
of cattle (13 %) and even increased milk production (Table 2).
Table 1: Number of cattle in Slovenia
| Year |
All cattle
|
All cows
|
Pregnant heifers
|
| 1985 |
557 206
|
222 551
|
33 200
|
| 1990 |
546 048
|
220 266
|
34 760
|
| 1995 |
477 400
|
207 423
|
29 466
|
| 1997 |
485 535
|
207 318
|
29 419
|
Better production results failed due to unfavourable farm size and herd
composition during the transition, being 3,5 cows per farm in 1990. It
has been increased to 6.1 cows per farm in 1998 after the new quality standards
have been accepted (Table 3).
The number of farms that have their milk purchased decreased to reach
20 000 farms today. Due to changes in the land owning structure the number
of state farms decreased to only 25 at the moment. They produce 8.7 % of
all purchased milk in Slovenia. Ten years ago state farms produced 13.8
% of all purchased milk in Slovenia.
Table 2: Total amount of purchased milk and average price of purchased
milk
| Year |
No. of herds
|
No. of
cows
|
Purchased milk, total*
|
Average price of milk
|
Average price of milk, ECU
|
| 1985 |
58 194
|
175 696
|
351 560 000
|
40 din
|
|
| 1990 |
43 656
|
161 992
|
360 560 000
|
3,46 SIT
|
|
| 1993 |
36 327
|
148 802
|
330 677 000
|
27,28 SIT
|
0,22
|
| 1994 |
|
|
355 052 000
|
35,80 SIT
|
0,25
|
| 1995 |
|
|
392 502 000
|
38,92 SIT
|
0,26
|
| 1996 |
27 384
|
129 724
|
387 128 000
|
41,72 SIT
|
0,24
|
| 1997 |
25 089
|
128 245
|
387 291 967
|
ca. 50 SIT
|
0,26
|
| 1998** |
19 971
|
|
414 278 000
|
ca. 61 SIT
|
0,29
|
* Source: Statistical yearbook (1980, 1985, 1990, 1993, 1996, 1997)
** According to data of PZPS - GIZ
Since 1990 the quality of purchased milk has been improved significantly
(higher contents of fat and proteins in milk, less TNMO and SCC). Therefore
the quality of milk can be compared to that in the neighbour countries
(Italy, Austria, Germany). Despite changes in eating habits and higher
consumption of milk and milk products, Slovenia has milk surpluses that
are intended to be sold on ex-Yugoslav markets and the EU market. Now 15
dairies purchase milk in Slovenia. The quality of purchased milk differs
among dairies. For example, there are two dairies with very high quality
of milk - 97 % of purchased milk is of extra, i.e. first quality class.
Merging of dairies in Slovenia will probably result in the future in two
dairy systems, one in the eastern and the other in the western part of
the country.
Table 3: Herd structure and number of cows per recorded herd
| Year |
Percentage of farms with number of cows, %
|
No. of farms
|
Cow/ farm
|
| |
1 - 4
|
5 - 9
|
10 - 15
|
> 15
|
|
|
| 1975 |
80
|
19
|
0,7
|
0,3
|
49 509
|
2,2
|
| 1980 |
78,2
|
19,2
|
2,2
|
0,4
|
52 221
|
2,6
|
| 1985 |
78,6
|
18
|
2,7
|
0,7
|
58 130
|
2,86
|
| 1990 |
73,5
|
21,3
|
3,6
|
1,6
|
43 613
|
3,53
|
| 1992 |
71,8
|
22,0
|
4,6
|
1,6
|
38 154
|
3,92
|
| 1994 |
64,9
|
24,8
|
7,8
|
2,5
|
31 674
|
4,27
|
| 1995 |
62,0
|
28,6
|
6,7
|
2,6
|
30 012
|
4,36
|
| 1996 |
61,2
|
27,0
|
8,5
|
3,3
|
27 356
|
4,52
|
| 1997 |
58,5
|
28,1
|
9,4
|
4,0
|
25 063
|
5,12
|
| 1998 |
|
|
|
|
19 947
|
6,10
|
The introduction of new regulation - a quality progress
Some significant changes in number of farms, herd structure and quality
of milk were noticed in 1993 when new regulations on milk payments
were introduced, which are based on EU standards for total number of micro-organisms.
Somatic cell count in milk was introduced in 1996. Unfortunately somatic
cell count was not a practice in milk recording before 1996 (Tables 4 and
5).
Table 4: Microbiological quality of milk, percent in each quality
class according to new milk quality regulations
| Year |
Number of micro-organisms - TNMO/ml (plate count/ml)
|
| |
to 500 000
|
to 400 000
|
to 300 000
|
to 100 000
|
to 50 000
|
| 1992 |
54,3
|
|
|
|
|
| 1993 |
|
|
60,9
|
44,1
|
28,7
|
| 1994 |
|
87,2
|
|
60,4
|
43,5
|
| 1995 |
|
93,0
|
|
78,6
|
61,5
|
| 1996 |
|
93,7
|
|
82,3
|
63,2
|
| 1997 |
|
94,7
|
|
82,8
|
68,3
|
| 1998 |
|
95,7
|
|
84,0
|
69,1
|
Table 5: Somatic cell counts and averages SCC in "samples from stables"
(analyses were performed at Institute for Microbiology of Veterinary Faculty)
| Year |
Number of milk samples
|
% samples
> 500.000 cells/ml
|
Average SCC in milk from pool
|
| 1980 |
21 454
|
27,3
|
497 000
|
| 1985 |
25 664
|
29,2
|
514 000
|
| 1990 |
29 654
|
30,3
|
479 000
|
| 1995 |
76 245
|
24,0
|
413 000
|
| 1996 |
83 698
|
21,8
|
352 000
|
| 1997 |
79 257
|
17,1
|
317 000
|
Source: Zorko, Pengov: Stanje na podrozju mastitisa v Sloveniji. Simpozij
o mastitisu, Ljubljana, 1998)
Table 5 shows that the percentage of samples of milk with SCC > 500
000 decreases as well as the average SCC in milk that is delivered to dairies
by farmers. A significant advance in quality of milk was noticed after
1993, which was caused by new Regulation, new purchase price system, higher
level of knowledge and perception of farmers who had milk purchased.
Model of formation new purchase price system for milk
New purchase price for one litre of milk is formed according to
the following model:
PPP = M + B + K
PPP = purchase price for producer
M = (ME) x determined percent of fat
ME = price per fat unit = 6.77 SIT/litre
B = (BE) x determined percent of proteins
BE = price per protein unit = 7.97 SIT/litre
K = bonus for quality class = IC x percent of increasing or decreasing
bonus regarding the quality class and somatic cell count.
IC = basic purchase price of milk - i.e. milk with 3 % milk fat and
3.5 % proteins, which is 50.5 SIT/litre at the moment.
According to the Regulation the basic price of milk increases or decreases
regarding the achieved quality class:
E quality class (up to 50 000 mo/ml) + 5 % + 5 % for SCC*
1st quality class (50 001 do 100 000 mo/ml) 0 % + 5 % for
SCC*
2nd quality class (100 001 do 400 000 mo/ml) - 5 %
3rd quality class (400 001 do 800 000 mo/ml) - 15 %
*Regarding the somatic cell count in milk the basic price can be increased
by 5 % for the E quality milk and 1st quality milk that contains
less than 400 000 somatic cells per litre.
At the moment Slovene milk producers can gain 10 % of bonus for quality
milk (up to 50 000 TNMO and up to 400 000 SCC), which is 55.15 SIT or 0,27
ECU per litre of purchased milk with 3.7 % milk fat and 3.15 % proteins.
Quality control of purchased milk
The quality of purchased milk is controlled by dairy employees or
authorised persons from co-operatives (both). Deeds of sale between milk
producers and dairies are addressed to co-operatives. Samples of milk are
taken in the milk collecting units or at producers’ according to the following
schedule:
-
at least twice a month for fat and protein control
-
at least twice a month for somatic cell count
-
TNMO is determined at least once a month
-
freezing point of milk is determined according to circumstances
-
contents of anti-bodies and inhibiting matters are determined according
to circumstances.
Regular control and regulations helped to improve the quality of purchased
milk in Slovenia in the last few years. Also expert services and education
of milk producers were important. Those producers who could not follow
the required quality ceased from milk production and started to rear foster
cows or pigs but some of them even stopped farming for good.
Organisation of extension services for milk production
Besides above mentioned facts the milk quality in Slovenia is also
influenced by the Agricultural Extension Services and the Milk Recording
Service, with Selection Service of Slovenia also having great influence
the milk quality after transition in Slovenia.
-
Agricultural extension service
Agricultural Extension Service was founded in 1990 and acts within departments
for extension of agriculture at regional agricultural and animal production
veterinary centres. The Service is a part of Administration of Republic
of Slovenia for extension of agriculture, which is a part of Ministry of
Agriculture, Forestry and Food. Before 1990 the extension service functioned
on two levels: in the regions of agricultural and veterinary institutions
one finds expert extension workers, while in co-operatives agricultural
extension workers and production organisers are operating. Extension service
was financed by state (one third), local community (one third) and agricultural
co-operative (one third). After 1990 the extension service has been financed
by state - MAFF.
The objectives of extension service are in accordance with the objectives
of Slovenian agricultural policy. They were determined in the Development
Strategy of Slovenian Agriculture (1993). The main objectives are:
-
direction of development of countryside
-
income increase on farms by diminishing production costs,
-
better education and training of farmers and their family members in farm
management
-
promotion of production that maintains natural equilibrium and fertility
of soil,
-
harmonisation of production with natural capacities and markets
-
provision of suitable expert education and training of agricultural extension
service officers and producers.
Agricultural Extension Service involves 294 experts who work all over Slovenia
and are linked to 8 departments for agricultural extension at regional
agricultural and animal production veterinary institutions. There are 64
agricultural specialists employed in 8 departments for agricultural extension
and at expert extension service. There are 17 specialists in animal production
from those 11 specialists are engaged in cattle production (3 specialists
for production and quality of milk). Other specialists work on plant production
and agricultural economy. Extension service officers are in charge of farm
families and extra activities on farms and do field-work in 60 administrative
units. In 60 units for agricultural extension there are 181 male extension
service officers and 49 female extension service officers in charge of
farm families and extra activities on the farms.
-
Milk recording service
Milk recording in Slovenia is manifold. Milk recording results and prints
help breeders to manage herds and farms. It is very important that milk
recording results are precise and available to breeders in two or three
days after the recording. Breeders are helped to manage the herds by experts
from advising and veterinary insemination services. Selection is managed
by experts from selection service. Recording results and all other information
obtained by our service is very helpful to all expert services that are
included in the production of quality milk and breeding animals.
Milk recording is especially important for selection service. In Slovenia
210 000 cows and 30 000 heifers are inseminated every year: 65 000 cows,
which is 39 % of all dairy cows, are milk recorded. About 600 cows are
bull dams, which is less than 1 % of recorded cows. Prospective bull dams
are chosen and registered as dams of future bulls on the base of calculated
breeding values and measured physical traits and exterior marks. Bull dams
are inseminated by semen of best bulls of a certain breed (domestic and
imported).
Slovenia is included into international comparison of breeding value
estimations of bulls and transfer all data regularly to INTERBULL Centre
to Uppsala. Recording results are important from information point of view
and are at disposal of various governmental and expert bodies like Ministry
of Agriculture, Chamber of Agriculture, Chamber of Veterinary, dairies
and meat processing units, and Statistical Office of Slovenia.
Organisation and financing of milk recording
Milk recording service in Slovenia is organised and financed by
Ministry for Agriculture, Forestry and Food. Cattle Service of Slovenia
consists of central service (Agricultural Institute and Biotechnical Faculty)
and six regional centres (Murska Sobota, Ptuj, Celje, Kranj, Ljubljana
and Nova Gorica).
Six laboratories analyse milk and belong to six regional centres. Laboratories
have MILKOSCANS (diverse capacity). Some laboratories have FOSSOMATIC for
somatic cell counts. The mentioned six laboratories and other laboratories
that analyse milk for dairies, are part of network for milk sample exchange.
Laboratory of Institute for Dairying that is a part of Biotechnical Faculty
- Zootechnical Department (BF) is a referral laboratory. Laboratory of
the BF Institute for Dairying is included into international network for
assessment of results because Slovenia is a member of ICAR Reference Laboratory
Network led by Mr. Oliver Leray. Slovenia exchanges results with referral
laboratories in Europe (France, Germany, Denmark). All laboratories in
Slovenia are included into the national ring test and are calibrated with
referral laboratory of Institute for Dairying.
The following table displays herds and milk recorded cows by regional
centres
Table 6: Number of herds and milk recorded cows - review by regional
centres in 1997
Regional
centre
|
Herds, A + AP methods
|
Cows, A + AP methods
|
|
Family farms
|
Farms
|
Total
|
Family farms
|
Farms
|
Total
|
| Murska Sobota |
1 839
|
-
|
1 839
|
10 287
|
-
|
10 287
|
| Ptuj |
1 539
|
3
|
1 542
|
11 946
|
339
|
12 285
|
| Celje |
998
|
4
|
1 003
|
11 377
|
595
|
11 972
|
| Kranj |
336
|
6
|
342
|
5 139
|
1 060
|
6 199
|
| Ljubljana |
1 848
|
9
|
1 857
|
15 273
|
3 342
|
18 615
|
| Nova Gorica |
870
|
5
|
875
|
5 390
|
975
|
6 365
|
| Total |
7 430
|
27
|
7 458
|
59 412
|
6 311
|
65 723
|
Table 7 shows the average number of cows per milk recorded herd in each
regional centre. Smaller herds are in the eastern part of Slovenia where
milk production has declined due to pig production and in the western part
of Slovenia (Primorska) where farming has declined owing to aggravated
production conditions. Young people leave this mountain and carst region
and only elderly people remain.
Table 7: Average number of cows per milk recorded herd referring
to sector and controller in 1997
Regional
centre |
Cow : herd ratio
|
No. of all
controllers
|
Average No.
cows per control.
|
| Family farms |
Farm
|
Total
|
| Murska Sobota |
5,6
|
-
|
5,6
|
29
|
355
|
| Ptuj |
7,8
|
113
|
8,0
|
48
|
256
|
| Celje |
11,4
|
149
|
11,9
|
44
|
272
|
| Kranj |
15,3
|
177
|
18,1
|
18
|
344
|
| Ljubljana |
8,3
|
371
|
10,0
|
66
|
282
|
| Nova Gorica |
6,2
|
195
|
7,3
|
32
|
199
|
| Total |
8,0
|
234
|
8,8
|
237
|
277
|
Milk recording is financed by government for the time being. In Slovenia
about 240 controllers are employed and about 20 senior controllers who
are responsible for milk recording and selection, registration and identification,
and pedigree data keeping in our herds.
The average cost of milk recording per cow equals to 180 kg of milk
a year. The expenses are paid by government. Breeders would like in future
to have other traits measured, like somatic cell count, contents of urea
in milk, nutrition and economic data, and other prints within milk recording
services but they should pay a part of costs for them. Government will
in future not be able to cover all milk recording costs. Therefore financial
resources for milk recording and animal registration should be rationally
used. Serious considerations have already been started in connection with
the AT method, reduction of laboratories for determination of milk traits
and quality of milk and restructuring of control services for milk recording
and data processing.
-
Quality assurance and Slovene dairy laboratories
Presently there are fifteen laboratories dealing with quality estimation
in Slovenia. Six of them are from milk recording service of Slovenia, others
from dairies. The national reference laboratory in charge of harmonisation
of methods and procedures with national laboratories of other countries,
members of international associations, will be appointed.
The Laboratory of the Institute for Dairying at the Zootechnical Department
of the Biotechnical Faculty is presently in charge of such activities.
The laboratory organises inter-laboratory comparative tests for precision
control of results, obtained by instrumental methods and also prepares
reference materials. It is a member of INTERLAB and involved in the international
laboratory control of precision of milk and dairy products analyses, organised
by MUVA, Kempten, Germany, CECALAIT, Poligny, France, as well as BACTOSCAN
MILKSTANDARD Service, Wangen, Germany. In this way the laboratory practically
takes part in organising the European network of dairy laboratories. (Golc,
1998)
Conclusions
In the period of transition, 1990 - 1998, Slovenia managed to maintain
the number of cows and milk production on almost the same level as before
the transition. Milk production has been increasing since 1993 and there
are some milk surpluses.
Market demands and new regulations on quality of milk introduced in
1993 caused the decrease of family farms and state farms with market production
of milk by 50 %.
The composition of milk (fat and proteins) and especially microbiological
quality after 1993 has obviously been improved and reached the EU level.
Family farms that keep market production of milk have improved technologies,
genetic potential of animals and productivity of cows and productivity
of work.
Number of cows per family farm with market milk production has been
slowly increasing (on 6.1 cows/farm in year 1998).
Amounts of purchased milk per cow increased on family farms by 1.050
litres and on state farms by about 730 litres in the period from 1990 to
1998.
Breed composition of milk producing cows has been changed in favour
of Black and White cows (HF).
The government contributes to the above changes by financing extension
services, milk recording and selection services, and by price policy and
subsidies.
The problem is not enough attractive loans for more rapid changes of
farm size and modernisation of milk production.
Quite large extension and milk recording services due to farm structure
in Slovenia and large number of dairies are still being reorganised and
shall be reduced in future.
References
-
Cattle Breeding in Slovenia. Govedorejska sluzba Slovenije. Ljubljana,
1997.
-
Golc-Teger Slavica: Adapting the milk and milk products' quality control
to the directives of the European Union. 6th Int. Symp. »Animal
Science Days«, Portoroz, Slovenia, Sept. 16-18, 1998, s. 229 - 235
-
Klopcic Marija, Podgoršek P.: Rezultati kontrole produktivnosti krav v
letu 1997. Govedorejski zvonci, 3(1998)1
-
MKGP: Slovensko kmetijstvo, gozdarstvo in zivilstvo v številkah. Ljubljana,
1997.
-
Statistical yearbook Republic of Slovenia (1980, 1985, 1990, 1993, 1996,
1997)
-
Uredba o nacinu oblikovanja odkupne cene kravjega mleka. Uradni list Republike
Slovenije, št. 89 (1998), s. 8475 -8476
-
Zorko Olga, Hocevar J., Golc Slavica, Valinger E.: Prireja kakovostnega
mleka. Kmecki glas, 1997, št. 3
Chart 1: Organization scheme of dairy cattle services in Slovenia
|
MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, FORESTRY and FOOD
|
|
ê
|
ê
|
é
|
| AGRICULTURAL EXTENSION SERVICE
8 Department
60 administrative units
294 experts
64 agricultural extension
specialists
17 specialists for animal
production
11 specialists for cattle
production
3 specialists for produc- tion and quality of milk |
CATTLE BREEDING SERVICE
Central
District
(6 institutions)
Insemination
(2 insemination centres)
Laboratories (6)
237 controllers
20 senior controllers |
ASSOCIATION OF CATTLE BREEDERS OF SLOVENIA
Cattle Breeding Association
Breeder’s unions for:
- Simmental breed
-
Brown breed
-
Black and white breed
-
Meat breeds and meat production
Cattle breeding associations
|
|
ê
|
ê
|
é
|
-
education and training of farmers
-
direction of development of countryside
|
-
Registration
-
Recording
-
Insemination
-
Breeding program and pedigree
|
- Sell
- Influence on prices and breeding
- Exhibitions
|
|
ê
|
ê
|
é
|
BREEDERS
-
65 000 cows in milk recording by 7.500 breeders
-
150 000 numbered and registered cows
-
170 000 dairy cows
-
40 000 suckler cows
-
200 000 cows and pregnant heifers inseminated by 60.000 breeders
-
240 000 cows and pregnant heifers by 70.000 breeders
|
|