CONCLUSIONS
Sustainable farming systems in the CEECs are connected with preserving
the resource base and environmental conservation, as well with the maintenance
of productivity and the economic viability of the farming system. Ecological
and economical factors go hand in hand to establish a sustainable agriculture.
The following conclusions can be drawn based on this review:
-
A conceptual base for "operationalization" is offered by the concepts of
productivity, profitability, stability, diversity, flexibility, time dispersion,
sustainability, complementarity and environmental compatibility and equitability.
Productivity
is defined as the output of valued product per unit of resource input.
Profitability can be measured by gross margins for activities, by various
whole-farm measures or by various discounting measures. It seems like profitability
is generally very low in most CEECs. The state of stability, which
signifies the ability to maintain productivity despite normal fluctuations
and cycles in the environment, is not clear from the review. It may vary
from country to country. Typically, stability can be measured through the
coefficient of variation. The measures of diversity, flexibility
and time dispersion are not resolved in this review. Diversity
can be measured through Simpson’s diversity index, whereas flexibility
can be quantified by the variety of uses to which products can be put.
Time dispersion can be measuredthrough a time dispersion index.
Sustainability, or the ability of a system to maintain productivity
while subject to stress or shock, does not seem to be in good shape in
the CEECs. The state equitability,
or the evenness of the distribution
of the agroecosystem’s productivity among the human beneficiaries, seems
to be problematic, at least in terms of evenness in the distribution of
land. Finally, environmental compatibility is not present because
many of the natural resources that are relied upon, such as soil and water,
are being degraded.
-
In spite of the narrow definition of sustainability given above, all nine
concepts reflect the three wider dimensions of sustainable farming systems.
Sustainability needs to be empirically applied on the farming systems level.
However, sustainability needs to be defined first on a national level and
then proceed downward conceptually.
-
Completion of initiated privatization programs while granting full property
rights to the land owners are preconditions for the long-term improvement
of the productive capacities of farming systems. If the users of land do
not have clearly defined property rights, they are not going to make investments
for the long-term improvement of soils and productive assets.
-
The low profitability of farming systems makes it difficult to take into
account environmental factors, which in the long run will affect the population’s
welfare to a significant degree. To improve profitability and thus to make
it possible for farmers to develop their farms and farming systems, it
is necessary to first arrange proper credit possibilities and proper nutrient
management systems (e.g. for manure and adequate fertilization).
-
In addition, functioning credit markets are missing, are based on personal
relations or excludes smaller- or medium-sized farms. Because of unstable
conditions farmers are also reluctant to take the financial risks presented
by loans. Taking into account the liquidity constraints and high interest
rates often demanded by private money lenders, it would be of utmost importance
to improve credit markets, possibly through establishment of micro-loans
schemes.
-
Most CEECs lack adequate extension systems, input and equipment supplies
and infrastructure. In virtually all CEECs, the extension system seems
to be inadequate or insufficient.
-
The sustainability of farming systems implies having control over environmental
problems. The most widespread and urgent problems seem to be erosion and
land degradation, the degradation of waterways, nutrient deficiency in
many soils, contamination of soil with pesticides and heavy metals and
the salinization of soils. Biodiversity is important locally, but it does
not seem to be the problem with the highest priority. It is possible to
use checklists in order to determine the factors affecting the sustainability
of farming systems. Such checklists have been provided in the section "Factors
affecting the sustainability of farming systems". The checklists are not
supposed to be entirely comprehensive, but they indicate which issues need
to be looked at carefully. A checklist is a first indication as to which
variables should be given attention.
The introduction of good agricultural practices or best management practices
offers a possibility for virtually all CEECs to reduce the negative effects
of agriculture on the environment. In some countries such systems may be
applicable quite soon, while other countries may have to complete the institutional
settings for land reform before such good agricultural practices can be
implemented.