Michael Riggs

Michael Riggs

Organization FAO
Organization type International Organization
Organization role
.
Country Italy
Area of Expertise
.

An enthusiastic member of the e-Agriculture Community since its founding, and a former Team Leader (lead facilitator). Active in the field of information and communication technologies for development. Currently a programme officer at the Asian and Pacific Training Centre for Information and Communication Technology for Development (unapcict.org), supporting ICTD capacity development intiatives in the Asia-Pacific region. A member of the ICTD Collective and of Orbicom.

This member participated in the following Forums

Forum e-Agriculture: looking back and moving forward

Question 3 (opens 2 Dec.) What is necessary to ensure ensuring that rural youth, women, the poorest...

Submitted by Michael Riggs on Mon, 12/02/2013 - 15:46

Copied from post of rachel sibande under Question 2.


Dear all,
Dwakatha, I want to share the Malawian experience in this space of Gender and ICTs in the agricultaral arena and the lessons that we have learned.
1. When we started off deployment of Esoko,  a web to sms platform through which smallholders were receiveing market prices and extension messages; we had not thouroyghly conducted an assessment on gender and its dynamics as relates to the targeted audience i.e. rural smallholders. As we closed the initial phase it was clear this was an oversight and had to be done. Hence I recommend that such assessments on access to eqipment such as cellphones,radios and other gadgets to be used for information service delivery , mapping of gender roles e.t.c should be done prior to deployment to design initiatives that will start addressing these gaps.
2. When we did the assessment through focus group discussions, one on one interviews, database checks and observations; it was clear that:
 - Over 65% of the agricultural workforce doing the work in the fields for food crops from land preparation through postharvest handling were women. Men were more involved in marketing.
 - Most women did not have access to cellphones yet information was sent through phone. 86% of male smallholders were registered to receive market and extension information via SMS on their cellphones while women smallholders only made 14% of those registered. The gender disparity is pretty wide in terms of access to te cellphones. From focus group discussions, it was interesting to note that men did not share some of the infromation on extension with their female counterparts regardless of the fact that it was the womn that did most of the farm work hence needed the information more. Men were not willig to let their wives have ceelphones for reasons ranging from that of  women being vulnerable to communicate with other man friends to others saying they just didnt think it was necessary for a woman to have a phone anyway.

We resolved to do the following inorder to start addressing these gaps:_
1. Encourage families i.e. husband and wife to attend trainings as an item, not as individual farmers.
2. During trainings emphasise the importance of sharing information
3. Bring in smallholder family role models to share their success stories with fellow farmers. Smllholders that share information and can link this to increased production and quality or even the ability to bargain for better prices and to make informed decisions with income.

Just thought I woupd share some of the experiences we have had and how we are dealing with issues and to gauge how others have dealt with similar instances elsewhere.

Submitted by Michael Riggs on Mon, 12/02/2013 - 15:45

Copied from post of mmmayzelle under Question 2.


dwakhata,  Thanks for highlighting some of the many challenges women face as they attempt to benefit and participate in the services made available to them through ICT.  

The vocabulary you employ (cultural prejudice, insecurity, fear, excited, inappropriate...) suggest that the discrimination women face is not isolated to ICT initiatives, but rather is very much ingrained in the surrounding culture.  Of course, that is not to say that our projects cannot help chip away at such cultural divides.

Interventions such as incentives for female participants and gender-based listener's clubs may make things easier for women in the short term, but in the long run they are still separating genders and suggesting that women are somehow different or merit different attention than men (this applies in some situations--such as health issues--but not, I believe, in professional arenas such as agriculture).  

The best solutions are those that promote equal treatment of both genders.  Examples include the consideration of gender issues in the planning stages and, most importantly, sensitization of people in power (in your example, the radio producers and presenter) that you rightly mention.  Another avenue is the engagement of "crusader" women in the spotlight of the project (in your example, as producers or presenters) who are willing to perhaps face some discrimination and hardship in the name of demonstrating that their gender is no different when it comes to business/agriculture/etc.  As we all know, putting a face and a personality on a "faceless" issue (such as gender discrimiantion) is the most effective way to change individuals' perceptions.  

Thanks for bringing up this hugely important point.

Submitted by Michael Riggs on Mon, 12/02/2013 - 15:43
Copied from post of dwakhata under Question 2.


The following  is based on my experience in the field(Mbale District-Uganda)

Challenges of integrating gender

1.      Cultural prejudice that continue to be used by men to control women.
2.      Insecurity of some men when their wives’ voices are frequently aired on the radio (either as star  or radio farmers) and when given phones to use.
3.      Lack of capacity by  the actors to identify and integrate gender in all stages of work.
4.      African women seem to fear their husbands rather than respecting them so it was not easy conduct interviews to  get their perspectives,or train them on the use of technology in presences of their husbands.
5.      Sometimes, male representatives and or service providers on the radio or other technology in dessemination of information get excited (sometimes use ‘inappropriate’ words) when females call in and this seems to annoy and discourage their husbands from allowing their wives to call in.

Recommendations for better integration of gender

  1. Tease out gender issues at planning stages
  2. Identify strategies to address gender issues e.g. the gender proposals for under beans 
  3. Affirmative action in favor of women for example in selecting beneficiaries, interviewees, enterprises  and technologies
  4. Provide instant incentives tagged to women’s participation. For example the presenter can promise to give a few kilograms of seed/T-shirt/cap for every woman who will call during the radio program. This incentive mechanism can be facilitated by partnering with seed/input companies/schools/banks/microfinance other institutions.
  5. Listener clubs for different categories of people (Youth, men, women, PWDs and mixed ones)
  6. Sensitize radio producers and presenters on gender
  7. Capturing testimonies from women and airing them. Better if these testimonies from women who have succeeded in collaborating with her husband e.g. her husband  allows her more access to funds

Question 2 (opens 27 Nov.) What critical challenges persist in our field, and what is needed to overcome these challenges...

Submitted by Michael Riggs on Thu, 11/28/2013 - 00:26
Eric, thank you for this comment and for homing in on a specific issue. Financing. 

Could you tell us more about why you think realistic financing is not available? 

Are there any possible solutions to this?
Submitted by Michael Riggs on Thu, 11/28/2013 - 00:23
Stephane and Megan and others, 

OK, we agree that demand driven content is a good thing. But where is the content coming from? And do we have examples of processes/systems that show the potential to reach a large number of people at managable cost?

There are quite a few cases of organizations (public and private) that struggle with this. What are we missing?
Submitted by Michael Riggs on Wed, 11/27/2013 - 16:14
Thank you Zahra for highlighting the important role of women here. Are there specific ways in which ICT initiatives have failed to properly address women and their needs?

Question 3, which opens on Monday, will look further into issues about access and appropriate targeting of ICT services.

Question 1 (opens 25 Nov.) What are the main achievements in the area of ICT for agriculture and rural development...

Submitted by Michael Riggs on Tue, 11/26/2013 - 23:39
Hi Rachel, would you please define "HCD" for us?
Submitted by Michael Riggs on Tue, 11/26/2013 - 16:00
Hi everyone. Great discussion going here. I want to make a few comments as moderator:

- It's clear mobiles are successfully entering rural communities, but remember to indicate the role that they play. (Megan, for example, had a point about direct communication.)

- If it's useful, characterize the type of farmer you refer to. Useful distinctions might be not only between farmers in developing countries vs. those in developed countries, but also farmers of commerical crops, small scale farmers, and those only producing food for their own subsistence.

- We're not only interested in farmers, but also fisherfolk, agribusiness (from input suppliers to middle men), cooperatives and other organizations, natural resoruce custodians, etc.

Thanks!
Submitted by Michael Riggs on Tue, 11/26/2013 - 04:32
Hi Alvarez. Thanks for sharing this. It is quite an interesting system of technologies and information you describe. Would you tell us a bit more? Specifically:
- Is this something that is already in place and producing results? Or is it a goal that we need to achieve?
- Do you knkow of anything similar to this in a developing country? (As I understand you are talking about Spain.)
THanks!
Submitted by Michael Riggs on Tue, 11/26/2013 - 03:26
Hi Rachel. So would you say that the involvement of young people in the development of mobile apps has been a success at this point? Or does there needs to be more work to empower young people to be successful in app development?

Become a member

As e-Agriculture Forum member you can contribute to ongoing discussions, receive regular updates via email and browse fellow members profiles.